分类: society

  • ‘I’m no snitch’

    ‘I’m no snitch’

    MONTEGO BAY, St James — A New York man charged with smuggling a large shipment of cannabis into Jamaica via Sangster International Airport has been ordered to pay thousands in fines by the St James Parish Court this Wednesday, closing a high-profile border contraband case that exposes gaps in cross-border cannabis movement amid partial legalization in both the U.S. and the Caribbean nation.

    Shaquel Morales, a resident of Queens, New York, faced four criminal charges: possession of cannabis (ganja), trafficking in ganja, illegal importation of ganja, and making a false declaration on immigration documentation. A separate conspiracy charge was ultimately dropped after prosecutors presented no supporting evidence. Morales was represented by local Jamaican defense attorney Martyn Thomas.

    Court documents and law enforcement reports outline the timeline of the incident, which unfolded around 10:30 a.m. on March 26. Acting on a tip, members of Jamaica’s law enforcement command were waiting in the Customs contraband search area when Morales exited an incoming flight from Miami, Florida, to undergo routine screening by a Jamaica Customs Agency contraband enforcement officer.

    During a preliminary search of Morales’ checked grey hard-shell suitcase, officers detected multiple tightly wrapped packages that field testing confirmed were cannabis. After being formally cautioned that unlicensed cannabis importation is a criminal offense under Jamaican law, Morales was moved to a secured secondary search facility for full evidence processing.

    At the secondary facility, Morales first told investigators he resided in Queens, New York, and provided the name of a local Jamaican hotel as his intended accommodation. When investigators cross-checked the information, they discovered the hotel he named had not operated in Jamaica for a number of years, and Morales could not produce any proof of a reservation. Further review of his mandatory C5 immigration declaration form showed he had listed the same defunct hotel as his Jamaican address, plus an Atlanta, Georgia residential address that did not match the Queens address he provided to officers — flags that confirmed investigators’ suspicions of a false declaration.

    When investigators confronted Morales about the non-existent hotel, he changed his account to claim a cousin would send someone to meet him at the airport, but he refused to provide his cousin’s full name or contact information. When pressed about who the shipment of cannabis was intended for, Morales famously told investigators, “I’m no snitch.” When asked who was scheduled to take him from the airport to his accommodation, he deflected again, responding, “It is mine, why you need to get a cab driver?” After that exchange, Morales declined to answer any additional questioning and invoked his right to have legal counsel present for further interrogation.

    A full forensic search of the suitcase uncovered 12 vacuum-sealed packages of cannabis, totaling approximately 14 pounds of the controlled substance, which were logged into evidence by investigators. Morales was taken into custody and transferred to the Montego Bay Police Station to await processing. During a formal interview on March 28 held with his defense attorney present, Morales entered a plea of not guilty to all charges laid against him.

    In his mitigation argument to the court, defense attorney Martyn Thomas painted Morales as a first-time offender who was misled by his family member. Thomas told the court that Morales traveled to Jamaica for a planned spring break trip, and his cousin — who operates a licensed cannabis dispensary in Jamaica and does business with a second dispensary based in Atlanta — asked Morales to transport the cannabis shipment from Atlanta to Jamaica for sale at the cousin’s dispensary. Thomas argued that Morales believed all required import permits had been secured by his cousin, and he was told clearing Jamaican customs with the cannabis would not present any problems.

    Thomas also addressed the false declaration charge, explaining that Morales completed his electronic C5 declaration mid-flight after realizing he had forgotten to fill it out ahead of time. With no confirmed accommodation arranged (his cousin was supposed to handle that, Thomas said), Morales entered the address of a Jamaican resort he had stayed at during a previous visit, with no intent to actually stay there. It was an impulsive, careless mistake, not a deliberate attempt to deceive, Thomas argued.

    On the claim that Morales entered the customs red channel (for travelers declaring goods), court clerks confirmed there was no record of Morales declaring the cannabis on any of his entry documentation. Thomas further emphasized that his client admitted he made a mistake, had no prior criminal convictions in either the U.S. or Jamaica, and posed no public safety risk to Jamaican communities. He requested the court hand down a non-custodial sentence rather than prison time.

    Before announcing sentencing, Parish Court Judge acknowledged that both the United States and Jamaica allow licensed medical and recreational cannabis dispensaries, but reminded Morales that cross-border importation still requires formal approval, regardless of domestic legal status. The judge also called out Morales’ “I’m no snitch” comment, noting that the phrase is widely associated with organized criminal activity and that Morales could have simply invoked his right to legal counsel instead of making the provocative statement.

    In the final sentencing, the court handed down four cumulative fines: $56,000 Jamaican dollars for possession of ganja (with 30 days prison in default of payment), $112,000 Jamaican dollars for dealing in ganja (30 days default), $112,000 Jamaican dollars for illegal importation of ganja (three months default), and $20,000 Jamaican dollars for making a false declaration (30 days default). The conspiracy charge against Morales was dismissed for lack of evidence.

  • Youth residential facility opens in St James

    Youth residential facility opens in St James

    On the pristine island of Barbados, a major milestone in child protection and youth empowerment has been reached with the opening of a purpose-built residential facility designed to house and support foster children on the island. Inaugurated on a Saturday, this new development marks the official expansion of Barbados’ child protection infrastructure, fulfilling a long-held mission to support vulnerable youth across the country.

    Developed by the non-profit Barbados Children’s Trust, this new initiative represents a significant step forward in Barbados’ efforts to provide safe, supportive housing for foster children, with a specific focus on helping them transition toward independent adulthood. The site, which was developed in collaboration with the non-profit Barbados Children’s Trust and the government’s Social Empowerment agency, now accommodates teenagers aged 12 to 18, with the specific goal of helping them transition from the more structured environment of the Nightingale Children’s Village into a setting that promotes independence and essential life skills.

    The campus has been thoughtfully designed to accommodate young people at different stages of their development, with dormitory-style accommodation for younger residents, while older teens benefit from more independent living arrangements, including private bedrooms and shared living spaces. The site comprises a 3-acre campus that includes a main residence, activities centre, sports pavilion, with capacity for 37 young people and residential staff.

    The overall design of the facility incorporates a strong focus on providing practical, hands-on training that will equip young people with valuable life and employability skills. For example, the central kitchen and laundry area has been designed to accommodate both everyday domestic use and commercial-style training, allowing residents to gain hands-on experience in food preparation and facility operations. Additional features include a beauty salon where residents can learn hair care and styling skills, with plans for a woodworking workshop to introduce other practical trades. Dedicated support spaces such as a doctor’s office, social worker’s office, and reflection room are part of the integrated model of care provided at the facility.

    Outdoor amenities include courts for netball, volleyball, and road tennis, along with a floodlit playing field, reflecting a deliberate emphasis on physical activity as part of behavioural development. The compound is fully secured with perimeter fencing, 24-hour surveillance systems, and controlled access, ensuring a safe, secure environment for residents and staff.

    According to Minister of People Empowerment and Elder Affairs Adrian Forde, this significant investment reflects the government’s ongoing commitment to safeguarding vulnerable youth and ensuring no child falls through the cracks. He thanked donors for their contribution to what he described as a life-changing initiative for vulnerable youth across Barbados.

    Forde stressed that young people must be treated as rights holders, not passive recipients of care, adding: “The words endless possibility must be imbued in our young people.”

    He said the facility would serve as a platform to equip residents with practical skills, including horticulture and culinary training, while also promising the addition of a recreational park to further enhance the environment for residents.

    The minister outlined a broader national strategy focused on preventative intervention, arguing that exposure to structured opportunities and supportive environments reduces the likelihood of harmful behaviours and improves long-term outcomes for vulnerable youth. He also pointed to the ongoing expansion of social services across communities, particularly in St Michael, aimed at delivering support with greater accessibility and responsiveness to community needs.

    Overall, the opening of this new facility represents a significant step forward in Barbados’ ongoing efforts to expand and improve child protection infrastructure across the country, fulfilling a long-held mission to support vulnerable youth and help them transition toward healthy, productive independent adulthood.

  • WATCH: Police comb the scene of shooting

    WATCH: Police comb the scene of shooting

    A late-night shooting has left four young people between the ages of 16 and 20 wounded, prompting law enforcement officers to launch a thorough search of the incident area for critical forensic evidence. The shooting unfolded in the corridor between Corn Alley and Nevis Street, in the immediate vicinity of the local Joe Mikes venue.

    Early preliminary accounts from law enforcement confirm the group was on foot moving through the neighborhood when sudden gunfire erupted. The victims sustained a range of non-life-threatening injuries, including wounds to the hand, torso side, and leg. As of the latest update, all four injured youths are still receiving hospital care, and medical teams confirm all patients remain in stable condition.

    Local law enforcement has not yet released additional details about potential suspects or motives for the attack, as the investigation remains an active and ongoing process. Investigators are continuing to interview witnesses and collect physical evidence from the crime scene to piece together the full sequence of events that led to the shooting.

  • WATCH: Two Men Arrested After Altercation at Paradise Casino, Escape Attempt Foiled

    WATCH: Two Men Arrested After Altercation at Paradise Casino, Escape Attempt Foiled

    A chaotic early-morning incident at Paradise Casino ended with two men in police custody Sunday, after a confrontation with law enforcement escalated into a short-lived attempt to escape. The sequence of events began when officers interacted with the pair at the popular gaming venue, though law enforcement has not yet released clear information about what triggered the conflict that turned the routine interaction into a public disturbance.

    As the situation unfolded, the younger of the two suspects allegedly managed to open the door of a marked police pickup truck and made a sudden break for freedom in a bid to avoid arrest. The escape attempt did not last long, however: responding officers acted swiftly, moving to cut off the suspect’s route, surround him, and take him back into custody within moments of his break for freedom.

    After the failed escape was resolved, both suspects were secured and transported from the casino location to local law enforcement facilities for processing. In the immediate aftermath of the incident, authorities confirmed that no reports of severe injuries to either suspects, officers, or bystanders at the casino had been filed. As of Sunday, local police investigations into the full context and root causes of the altercation remain active and ongoing, with more details expected to be released as the probe progresses.

  • Cultuurdrager en ondernemer Claudetta Toney (88) overleden

    Cultuurdrager en ondernemer Claudetta Toney (88) overleden

    Influential Surinamese entrepreneur and cultural icon Claudetta Toney passed away on the morning of April 5 at the age of 88, just one month shy of her 89th birthday. Toney leaves behind a decades-long legacy of public service, educational advancement and cultural preservation across the South American nation, with close associates remembering her as a driven yet compassionate leader dedicated to lifting up communities.

    Kortencia Sumter-Griffith, Toney’s long-time right-hand, described her late mentor as a straightforward, goal-oriented figure with a deeply rooted commitment to social good. Renowned for her meticulous organizational skills, Toney planned and arranged every detail of her own funeral service in advance, a reflection of her characteristic foresight and clear sense of purpose, Sumter told local outlet Starnieuws. “She was a woman who always knew exactly what she wanted, and we will honor every one of her instructions as we lay her to rest,” Sumter added.

    One of Toney’s most prominent crowning achievements came to fruition just months before her passing. In September of the previous year, the Claudetta Toney University of Suriname for Chemistry, Engineering & Research held its official opening, marking the fulfillment of a long-held dream for the advocate. Beyond higher education, Toney dedicated decades of work to advancing public access to alternative healthcare: through the SAGK foundation, she led advocacy efforts to push for national legislation that would grant formal recognition to alternative medicine practitioners.

    Toney was also a passionate steward of Surinamese cultural heritage. Through her work with the Fiti Fu Wini foundation, she spearheaded initiatives focused on preserving local cultural traditions and supporting their ongoing development for future generations. She also contributed to the development of a formal Code of Ethics for funeral directors, bringing professional standards to the sector.

    Active across multiple public and private sectors, Toney never lost sight of individual community needs. Beyond her large-scale institutional work, she provided direct, personal support to countless individuals and families facing hardship across Suriname. “She was juggling dozens of projects and initiatives at any given time, but she always made time to see people who needed help,” Sumter said. Following Toney’s pre-planned arrangements, funeral organizers will move forward with finalizing services in line with her explicit written instructions.

  • Statement from the National Secretariat for Human Security and Wellbeing

    Statement from the National Secretariat for Human Security and Wellbeing

    A fatal shooting in Keys Village overnight has claimed the life of a well-loved young St. Kitts and Nevis entertainer, prompting an official statement of mourning from the National Secretariat for Human Security and Wellbeing that also calls for collective action to curb violent crime across the federation. The victim, Jermaine “Chubby” Clarke, leaves behind family and a lasting legacy of cultural contribution that has left the entire nation reeling from his senseless death. In the statement released Sunday evening, 5 April 2026, the Secretariat extended its deepest condolences to Clarke’s family, friends, and loved ones, noting that his passing is not only a devastating blow to those close to him but a profound loss for the entire St. Kitts and Nevis cultural and entertainment community. The Secretariat emphasized that Clarke’s high-profile death within the creative sector serves as a stark reminder: every life cut short by gun violence and violent crime is an irreplaceable tragedy that ripples far beyond the immediate loss of an individual. Each shooting fractures families, destabilizes local communities, and erodes the core social fabric that holds the nation together. As the Easter holiday weekend continues, the agency issued a public call for all citizens and residents of St. Kitts and Nevis to prioritize responsible behavior, practice emotional restraint, and commit to resolving interpersonal conflicts through peaceful means. Even heated disagreements do not require escalation to violence, the statement noted, stressing that split-second choices during moments of tension carry permanent, life-altering consequences for all involved. To support communities navigating conflict and grief, the Secretariat reminded the public that it remains fully operational to provide targeted support and connect residents to critical resources, including professional counselling referrals and de-escalation intervention services. Individuals and families in need of support can reach the agency through multiple channels: calling 869-665-1067, sending a message via call or WhatsApp to 869-667-7257, or emailing directly at humansecurity@gov.kn. The agency also appealed to community members with information relevant to the ongoing investigation into Clarke’s killing to come forward. Those with details that can assist the Royal St. Christopher and Nevis Police Force can contact their nearest local police station, or submit anonymous tips via the Crime Stoppers hotline at 707. The statement guaranteed that all information shared with either law enforcement or the Secretariat will be treated with the strictest confidentiality and discretion. Against the backdrop of this latest tragedy, the Secretariat highlighted the substantial progress St. Kitts and Nevis has made in recent years to reduce violent crime and restore a widespread sense of public safety. The federation has recorded notable drops in homicide rates and other violent offenses, progress the agency attributes to a collaborative approach that combines robust law enforcement work with a public health framework for crime prevention that addresses both immediate safety threats and the root causes of violence. This progress is the product of collective national effort, the statement stressed, and it must be actively protected and expanded by all segments of society. “This is our home,” the statement read. “It requires each of us – as individuals, as neighbours, and as communities – working in partnership with law enforcement and national institutions, including the National Secretariat for Human Security and Wellbeing, to ensure that it remains safe and secure. Together, we can continue to build and sustain a more peaceful future for ourselves and for the generations to come.” This report is based on an official statement distributed to SKNVibes.com, which published the release unedited without correcting potential spelling or grammatical errors. The views expressed in the original statement do not necessarily reflect the positions of SKNVibes.com, its sponsors, or its advertisers.

  • Statement from the Antigua and Barbuda Dental Association Regarding the Devastating Fire at Gambles Medical Centre

    Statement from the Antigua and Barbuda Dental Association Regarding the Devastating Fire at Gambles Medical Centre

    A devastating fire that tore through Gambles Medical Centre in St. John’s has prompted the Antigua and Barbuda Dental Association to issue an official statement of solidarity and support for the dozens of medical and legal professionals who lost their workspaces and critical resources in the blaze. The association has shared that its leadership and membership are deeply shaken and saddened by the sudden, destructive event that has upended operations for dozens of providers at the multi-use medical facility.

    Among those hardest hit by the fire is Dr. Bernard Evan-Wong, owner of Gambles Medical Centre and a former Treasurer of the Antigua and Barbuda Dental Association. His dental practice, along with that of associate Dr. Sarika Mooteram, suffered extensive damage to clinical spaces, specialized dental equipment, and years of confidential patient records. The destruction extends far beyond dental care: six additional medical specialists, including oncologist Dr. Hanybal Yazigi, obstetrician-gynecologist Dr. Leon B. Stevens, internist and rheumatologist Dr. Sharon Cordner, pediatrician Dr. Edda Hadeed, and surgeon Dr. Asha Robins, also lost all of their clinic infrastructure and patient documentation in the fire. Several attorneys and other non-medical professionals who maintained office spaces at the centre have also suffered major losses, including irreplaceable legal and professional records.

    In the statement released by association president Dr. Deborah Akande — a credentialed dental professional with DDS, FAGD, FICD and MBA qualifications — the organization emphasized that this tragedy reaches far beyond the personal and professional setbacks for the providers who work at the facility. It marks a significant loss for the entire nation of Antigua and Barbuda, as thousands of local patients and clients rely on these practitioners for essential, life-sustaining care and critical services. The disruption created by the fire will inevitably create challenges for community members accessing routine and specialized care in the coming weeks and months.

    The entire association extended its deepest thoughts and prayers to all affected providers, their clinical and administrative teams, and the families of those impacted, who are navigating the uncertainty and loss of this devastating event. Dr. Akande’s statement closed with a respectful request to the general public, asking for patience, understanding and compassion as these professionals work to assess the full scope of their losses and begin the long process of rebuilding their practices. The association expressed unwavering confidence that the affected providers will draw on deep reserves of resilience and determination to overcome this tragedy, and will eventually resume their vital service to the Antigua and Barbuda community, stronger than they were before.

  • STATE OF BLOOD

    STATE OF BLOOD

    A wave of persistent brutal violence has shaken Trinidad and Tobago, with at least 30 people killed in targeted attacks, shootings and fatal assaults across the nation in the five weeks since the government imposed a new state of emergency (SoE) to curb rising crime, Deputy Police Commissioner Suzette Martin confirmed last Friday. The chilling death toll averages out to roughly one killing per day since the SoE took effect on March 3, defying official pledges to restore public safety.

    Among the victims are people from all walks of life, including high-profile figures, children, working professionals and even an elite athlete. One of the most high-profile killings took place on March 13, when controversial real estate developer Danny Guerra was ambushed and gunned down by two masked gunmen in a white car as he returned to his vehicle outside his Sangre Grande business premises. Just one week later, on March 17, 28-year-old female cricketer Rashme Deoajit was found stabbed to death with her throat slit in her Cedros home; a man known to the family has since been charged in connection with her murder.

    The violence has also claimed the lives of some of the nation’s most vulnerable citizens. On March 31, an 11-month-old toddler, Jayden Sutton, was shot and killed alongside his 25-year-old father Joseph Sutton as the pair slept in their St James home. Police confirmed the father had been a witness to a separate shooting earlier that month and was cooperating with investigators, suggesting the killing was a targeted retaliatory attack. On March 23, three young men – 17-year-old Jordan Cudjoe Burke, 22-year-old Ishmael Matthews, and 21-year-old Roberto Samuel Carlos – were gunned down in a hail of bullets inside a ground-floor bedroom at Burke’s family property in Penal. Burke was the son of deceased local businessman and community activist Cedric Burke. That same day, the beaten body of 20-year-old mentally ill David Ramlakhan was found abandoned in bushes 200 feet from his New Grant home, where he had been left to die.

    Other victims include serving soldiers, business owners, and everyday residents going about their daily routines. On March 14, 30-year-old soldier Jaelani Garcia Williams was ambushed and shot dead while approaching his SUV outside a Chaguanas mini-mart; investigators recovered a loaded pistol from Williams’ possession along with multiple spent shell casings from the shooter’s weapons. Four people were killed across separate incidents on March 15 alone, including three men in different shootings across Laventille, and an unidentified man whose decomposing body was found floating in a Sangre Grande pond. Multiple other killings between March and early April have left victims unidentified, as law enforcement struggles to keep pace with the surge in violence.

    The ongoing bloodshed directly contradicts assurances delivered by senior government officials when the new SoE was announced. At the time of the declaration, Attorney General John Jeremie stated the government was determined to “never allow this country to deteriorate into the taste of chaos and bloodshed which we met in May 2025 when we took office.” To date, the state of emergency has failed to break the pattern of daily violence that has gripped the nation, leaving communities reeling from a steady stream of deadly attacks.

  • ‘What’s the point of an SoE?’

    ‘What’s the point of an SoE?’

    A horrific double shooting that claimed the lives of a 25-year-old man and his 11-month-old son as they slept in their Dundonald Hill, St James home has sent shockwaves across Trinidad and Tobago, leaving a tight-knit community paralyzed by grief and fear, and reigniting fierce questions about the effectiveness of the country’s ongoing state of emergency (SoE) to curb spiraling violent crime.

    On Tuesday, Joseph Sutton and his infant son Jayden Sutton were gunned down in their bed in what residents describe as a new low for the region’s long-running gang violence crisis. When reporters from the *Sunday Express* visited the community two days later to speak with residents and family members, grief and fear hung heavy over the quiet, mostly empty residential street.

    Magnus Sutton, father of Joseph and grandfather of Jayden, shared the crippling pain that has driven his family from the home they once shared. “We couldn’t bear to be in the home,” he explained. “Every morning, Jayden would be up, playing and crawling about. Now he’s gone. My son would have been up early, tending to his common-law wife and child before running out to the mini-mart he operates down the road. Now he can’t do any of that. All the joy is gone. So that house is not a place we want to be right now.”

    Sutton added that while the wider nation has already shifted its attention to other events and political headlines, his family remains trapped in acute mourning, with no clear path forward. “I know there have been other murders since. I know politics is taking up the headlines, but we are still suffering. We are still taking it very hard. We honestly don’t know what to do or what comes next,” he said. As of last Thursday, the family was still finalizing double funeral arrangements, with a goal of setting a service date by the end of the week.

    Most residents declined to speak on the record, hiding behind locked doors out of fear of retaliation from local gangs. But those who agreed to share their views expressed overwhelming horror at the killing of an innocent child, a violence so senseless it has eroded the last shred of sense of safety even inside private homes.

    Local resident Sandra encapsulated the widespread anger and despair felt across the community: “People not even safe in their own homes again…. Sleeping and getting shot? And a baby, too? Nah, this country reaching somewhere real dark now. And all this happening in an SoE? What is the point then? Because it is clearly not working.”

    One long-time resident echoed that sentiment, noting that the unprovoked killing of an infant breaks even the unwritten rules of criminal conflict that once spared innocent bystanders and children. “This one hit hard,” he said. “It is not just another headline—it’s a baby. I still trying to wrap my head around that. If you come for a man, wrong is wrong, but you come for him. Back in the day, there was an order. These young, wannabe thugs have no care for anyone or anything anymore.”

    Another resident added that the attack has left the entire community unable to sleep soundly: “When children are getting killed, people are genuinely frightened to even sleep properly because we don’t know what is coming next.”

    This double murder is far from an isolated incident in St James, which has seen a steady surge of brutal gun violence over the past 18 months across Dundonald Hill, Belle Vue and surrounding neighborhoods. A timeline of major violent incidents in the area reads like a chronicle of growing chaos: Just two weeks before the double killing, on March 16, Joseph Sutton was already targeted in a separate shooting that left another man injured. In February, two men from Laventille, 20-year-old Israel Payson and 24-year-old Jubriel Worrell, were shot dead during Jouvert celebrations on Damien Street and Mucurapo Road. In January, 24-year-old Jair Gilkes and 21-year-old Miguel Joseph were killed in a shooting near the Belle Vue Community Centre, with a third man wounded. In December 2025, 56-year-old Nicole Ovid was beaten to death and her body left on a Finland Street pavement, with 60-year-old Kenneth Charles charged in connection with her killing. In May 2025, 28-year-old Mark Anthony Ellis was killed and his 20-year-old companion wounded in a drive-by shooting as they socialized under a shed on Alfred Richards Street. The earliest high-profile killing on record dates back to October 2022, when 30-year-old Korey Clarke and 31-year-old Samantha Patrick were found shot dead in their bed just off Dundonald Hill, leaving their unharmed seven-month-old daughter in the room with their bodies. Four men have since been charged in that double killing, along with weapons offenses.

    Even for a community long accustomed to the threat of violence, the brutal killing of a sleeping infant has pushed residents to a breaking point, with widespread calls for action to address the failure of current public safety measures to stem the tide of bloodshed.

  • Murder rate edges up in Western Division

    Murder rate edges up in Western Division

    Senior Superintendent Garvin Henry, the top law enforcement official for Trinidad and Tobago Police Service’s (TTPS) Western Division, has openly confirmed a modest but concerning uptick in homicide cases across the jurisdiction in 2024. In an exclusive interview with the *Sunday Express* conducted last week, Henry stated, “We are seeing an increase, I will admit. The last figures I saw showed a slight increase in murders in the Western Division, and that is of concern to us, and that is a major part of our focus.” Despite acknowledging the upward trend in killings, Henry stressed that local law enforcement cannot reverse this pattern without active collaboration from members of the public.