In a decisive legal ruling, the High Court of Saint Kitts and Nevis has comprehensively dismissed the constitutional challenge brought by the Eastern Caribbean Collective Organisation for Music Rights (ECCO) Inc. against the nation’s newly established copyright regulatory framework. The court delivered its final judgment on Thursday, February 19, 2026, ordering ECCO to pay the government EC$10,000 in legal costs.
The legal dispute centered on the Copyright Act No. 14 of 2024 and its accompanying Copyright (Collective Management Organisations) Regulations, 2024, which establish a comprehensive system for authorizing and overseeing collective management organizations operating within the federation. The government implemented this regulatory regime to enhance transparency, accountability, and protection for both promoters and creative professionals.
ECCO’s legal action sought multiple forms of relief, including a declaration that section 4(6) of the Regulations exceeded the authority granted by the parent Copyright Act. The organization additionally argued that the absence of transitional provisions in section 4 violated their legitimate expectations and requested an order of certiorari to invalidate the contested regulatory section.
The court rejected all aspects of ECCO’s claim, affirming that the Regulations were properly enacted within the scope of authority granted by the Copyright Act. This ruling represents a significant validation of the government’s approach to regulating copyright collective management organizations.
Legal representation for the government was provided by Solicitor General Simone Bullen-Thompson, while ECCO was represented by attorney Dane Victor Elliott-Hamilton. The judgment follows a previous interim ruling from June 2025, where ECCO similarly lost its bid for an interim injunction against the regulations.









