A Grand Bahama magistrate has sentenced Kenneth Farrington to 30 months imprisonment for a brutal, unprovoked attack on school principal Simone Butler-Cornish, who expressed both relief and disappointment at the judicial outcome while extending forgiveness to her assailant.
The assault occurred in June 2025 at McLean’s Town School in East End, Grand Bahama, when Farrington entered Ms. Butler-Cornish’s classroom under the pretext of requesting a student’s report card. As the educator turned to retrieve the document, Farrington struck her in the head with a metal pipe, causing significant injury. In testimony, Ms. Butler-Cornish described her desperate escape strategy: fleeing the classroom, collapsing outside, and feigning death to halt the attack.
Magistrate Charlton Smith delivered the sentence after considering Farrington’s criminal history, notably a prior assault conviction in 2022 for which he served 18 months. The magistrate characterized this previous offense as an aggravating factor in sentencing decisions.
The courtroom proceedings revealed troubling details about the attack and its aftermath. During trial, Farrington initially declined to apologize directly to his victim, instead proclaiming love for his fiancé seated in the gallery. Only after repeated prompting from the magistrate did he offer a tentative apology, stating, ‘Yes, I’m sorry. I don’t know what got into me.’
Prosecutor Superintendent Veron Rolle presented five witnesses, including the victim, school staff, law enforcement officers, and medical personnel. Evidence confirmed that Farrington admitted to the assault and assisted police in recovering the weapon used in the attack.
Educational authorities expressed mixed reactions to the sentencing. Steven McPhee, president of the Bahamas Educators Managerial Union, acknowledged the difficulty of accepting the sentence given the attack’s severity and Farrington’s criminal record. The union now focuses on ensuring comprehensive psychological and financial support for Ms. Butler-Cornish, including potential relocation to a safer educational environment.
District Superintendent Maneica Pratt described the prolonged legal process as ‘mentally draining’ while welcoming the resolution. She joined others in characterizing the 30-month sentence as somewhat lenient but acknowledged Farrington’s need for rehabilitation.
The case has prompted systemic reviews of school security protocols throughout the Bahamas. Education officials have drafted enhanced safety measures for school premises access, with proposals receiving positive reception from ministry leadership. Additional meetings with school police officers and plans to employ more security personnel reflect institutional efforts to prevent similar incidents.