分类： world

The International Court of Justice (ICJ) convened on November 25, 2025, to hear oral arguments from Belize and Honduras regarding Guatemala’s request to intervene in the ongoing sovereignty dispute over the Sapodilla Cayes, known as Cayos Zapotillos in Honduras. The hearing, presided over by Judge Iwasawa at the Peace Palace, marks a critical juncture in a conflict that began in 2022 over a cluster of islands in the southern Gulf of Honduras. Guatemala’s application to intervene, filed in December 2023, cites Article 62 of the ICJ Statute, which permits third-party involvement if a state’s legal interests may be impacted by the Court’s decision.

Belize, represented by Special Envoy Assad Shoman, expressed no objection to Guatemala’s intervention, provided it aids the Court in reaching an efficient resolution. Shoman emphasized Belize’s commitment to resolving territorial claims from both Guatemala and Honduras and urged the ICJ to coordinate hearings in the related cases of Guatemala v. Belize and Belize v. Honduras to avoid redundancy. Counsel Ben Juratowitch highlighted the distinct nature of the two cases, noting Belize’s sovereignty claims based on historical conduct since Honduras’ independence. He also contested Honduras’ recent assertion of traditional fishing rights, arguing it falls outside the Court’s jurisdiction under the Pact of Bogotá.

Honduras, however, vehemently opposed Guatemala’s intervention. Agent Patricia Licona argued that the request is unprecedented and undermines judicial principles. Professors Alejandro del Valle Gálvez and Francisco Pascual Vives criticized Guatemala’s application as a misuse of the intervention mechanism, warning it could introduce unrelated claims into the case. Professor Carlos Jiménez Piernas further asserted that Guatemala lacks a specific legal interest in the dispute.

The ICJ will reconvene to hear Guatemala’s second round of arguments, with a decision on the intervention request pending.

The International Court of Justice (ICJ) in The Hague commenced a pivotal hearing today, November 24, 2025, addressing the long-standing territorial dispute over the Sapodilla Cayes, a group of islands claimed by both Belize and Honduras. In a significant development, Guatemala has formally requested permission to intervene in the case, adding a new dimension to the decades-old conflict. The hearing marks the latest phase in a legal battle that reignited in 2022 when Belize filed its case against Honduras. The Sapodilla Cayes, referred to as Cayos Zapotillos by Honduras, are at the heart of this sovereignty dispute. ICJ President Iwasawa Yuji outlined the procedural timeline, noting that Belize’s application was based on the 1948 Pact of Bogotá, which provides a framework for peaceful dispute resolution in the Americas. The court has set deadlines for the submission of legal documents, with Belize’s memorial due by May 2, 2023, and Honduras’s counter-memorial by December 4, 2023. This case underscores the complexities of territorial claims in the region and the role of international law in resolving such disputes.

The longstanding territorial dispute between Guatemala and Belize has taken a new turn with Belize’s recent claim against Honduras, adding complexity to an already intricate legal battle. The International Court of Justice (ICJ) in The Hague is now faced with the challenge of addressing two overlapping cases concerning sovereignty over key islands in the southern waters of Belize. Guatemala has emphasized that this is not the first time these islands have been at the center of a legal showdown, as the country and Belize have been engaged in a separate case since 2019 over the same territory. Belize’s new claim against Honduras, filed just days before Guatemala was due to submit its reply in the ongoing Guatemala/Belize case, has created a procedural dilemma for the court. Guatemalan Ambassador Ana Cristina Rodriguez Pineda highlighted the interconnectedness of the two cases, noting that Belize has acknowledged this overlap in its correspondence with Honduras. She suggested that hearing the merits of both cases consecutively could ensure consistency and efficiency, particularly if Guatemala is allowed to intervene. The outcome of these disputes holds significant implications for regional sovereignty and international legal precedents.

The Sapodilla Cayes, a pristine cluster of fourteen islands nestled where the Caribbean meets the Gulf of Honduras, are at the heart of a high-stakes territorial dispute. Renowned for their turquoise waters, vibrant coral gardens, and rich biodiversity, these islands are more than a marine sanctuary—they are a geopolitical flashpoint. For decades, Guatemala and Honduras have laid competing claims to the cayes, turning this remote paradise into a battleground for sovereignty and security. The International Court of Justice (ICJ) is now tasked with determining the rightful owner of this strategic and ecologically vital region, a decision that could reshape the geopolitical landscape of Central America.

The Sapodilla Cayes Marine Reserve, which has expanded eightfold to over 300,000 acres since 2021, is a testament to Belize’s commitment to conservation. Managed by the Toledo Institute for Development and Environment (TIDE) with just seven rangers, the reserve faces significant challenges, including illegal fishing by Guatemalan and Honduran fishers. Armed and often resistant to arrest, these fishers employ destructive methods such as gill nets and longlines, threatening the fragile ecosystem. Joint patrols by TIDE and the Belize Coast Guard, including operations like Lighthouse and Corona Reef Patrols, aim to safeguard the area’s biodiversity and enforce fisheries guidelines.

As the ICJ hears arguments on Guatemala’s intervention in the Belize-Honduras dispute, the stakes are immense. A ruling could either resolve the long-standing territorial claims or leave the issue unresolved, jeopardizing Belize’s maritime entitlements. Meanwhile, the broader case of Guatemala’s claim to Belizean land and maritime areas remains pending, with oral hearings yet to commence. The Sapodilla Cayes, a symbol of natural beauty and geopolitical tension, stand at the crossroads of conservation and conflict, their fate hanging in the balance.

In a recent development, Guatemala has sought to intervene in Belize’s legal case against Honduras concerning the Sapodilla Cayes, asserting that the islands overlap with its own territorial claims. This move reignites a decades-long dispute, despite previous assurances of peaceful resolutions. Beyond the geopolitical implications, Belizean law student Ethan Singh has drawn a compelling connection between sovereignty and environmental stewardship. In a detailed blog post, Singh, a student at Washington College of Law, examined Belize’s adherence to international environmental treaties and its impact on the nation’s territorial integrity. Singh traced Belize’s environmental commitments back to the 1992 United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change, followed by the 2015 Paris Agreement, and the recent Biodiversity Beyond National Jurisdiction Treaty, which Belize was among the first to endorse. He emphasized the principle of precaution in international environmental law, advocating for proactive measures to prevent environmental degradation. Singh highlighted Belize’s dedication to preserving its forested lands, contrasting sharply with neighboring Guatemala. This commitment, he argued, underscores Belize’s role as a leader in environmental advocacy, particularly for small island nations. As tensions over territorial claims persist, Singh’s analysis offers a fresh perspective on the intersection of environmental policy and national sovereignty.

In a remarkable display of international cooperation and swift action, the Belize Coast Guard successfully rescued four individuals from a distressed vessel near Gladden Spit over the weekend. The operation, initiated after a distress signal was relayed by the Honduran Navy, saved three U.S. nationals and one Mexican citizen who had embarked from Placencia on November 21, bound for Roatán. The vessel, named The Wet Spot, was discovered grounded on the reef, prompting an immediate response from Belizean authorities. Rear Admiral Elton Bennett, Commandant of the Belize Coast Guard, provided insights into the rescue, highlighting the challenges of navigation in the area and the seamless coordination between Belize and Honduras. All individuals were evacuated safely, with three transported to Placencia and the captain remaining aboard during the grounding. A comprehensive marine investigation led by the Police Port Authority will determine the cause of the incident, while the Department of Environment will assess the damage to the reef. The rescue underscores the importance of international collaboration in maritime emergencies and the prioritization of human safety in such operations.