What was shaped up to be a carefully coordinated large-scale robbery has ended in an embarrassing failure for five masked suspects, after a critical piece of their stolen heavy equipment broke down just as they were poised to escape with hundreds of thousands of dollars in cash, newly released official police reports have confirmed.
The botched plot kicked off shortly before midnight on a Wednesday, when two on-duty security guards at Courland Beach Sports Arena were ambushed by two attackers clad in dark clothing. One of the assailants was armed with a loaded firearm, and the pair immediately restrained and searched the guards, demanding they hand over keys for a white Mitsubishi work truck and a yellow Caterpillar backhoe. When the guards explained they did not carry the keys for the equipment, the gunmen ransacked on-site storage and personal bags, before tying the guards’ hands and feet and forcing them to lie face-down on the ground. In a striking detail that has drawn public attention, one of the suspects was wearing a cape and hood that matched the iconic costume of comic book hero Batman. Before leaving the scene, the attackers warned the guards that a third accomplice was posted as a lookout along the nearby fence line, and that any attempt to move or call for help would be met with force.
Minutes after the assailants departed, the guards heard the stolen truck and backhoe being driven off the property. It took the guards nearly an hour to free themselves from their restraints; once loose, they counted their losses and found that only $200 in cash had been stolen from one guard’s personal wallet. The value of the two stolen pieces of equipment, however, far outstripped that small take: the Mitsubishi truck was appraised at $412,000, and the Caterpillar backhoe was valued at $850,000, bringing the total value of stolen property from the arena to $1.262 million.
Just over two hours after the initial ambush, at approximately 2:05 a.m., a resident living in an upper floor of the Supreme Plaza building in Plymouth, overlooking a First Citizens Bank ATM on Shelbourne Street, was jolted awake by a loud noise that sounded like a vehicle ramming into the commercial structure. Curious, the resident looked out from an upstairs office window and spotted a masked man operating the stolen backhoe, which had already smashed a large hole in the exterior wall that housed the ATM’s reinforced vault. Parked nearby, a white three-tonne truck – the same stolen Mitsubishi from the arena – waited with four more masked suspects, ready to carry the vault away.
The witness immediately placed a call to local law enforcement, and watched from his vantage point as the backhoe wrenched the entire ATM vault free from the building’s foundation. The gang then made repeated attempts to hook the heavy vault to the backhoe and lift it onto the waiting truck – but that is where their carefully laid plan fell apart. The backhoe had sustained critical structural damage during the wall-demolition process, and it completely broke down mid-lift, leaving the suspects with no way to load the 238,000 vault onto their escape truck.
Trapped and with police already en route, the five suspects were forced to abandon their entire operation. They fled the scene in the stolen Mitsubishi truck, leaving behind the disabled backhoe, the damaged building, and the untouched ATM vault that still held their intended target: $641,000 in cold, hard cash. Law enforcement later assessed the damage to the bank and plaza building, estimating that structural repairs would cost $185,000, plus an additional $40,000 to replace two destroyed First Citizens Bank signs.
After securing the scene, investigators pulled surveillance footage from nearby cameras that clearly captured the five masked suspects during the attempted robbery. Police confirmed this week that they have already identified two persons of interest connected to the failed heist, and the investigation remains active as officers work to track down the remaining suspects and recover the stolen Mitsubishi truck that the gang escaped in.