Land Minister urges patience, says lawsuit could ‘open can of worms’

A political standoff over controversial pre-election land allocations in St. Vincent and the Grenadines has escalated, with 215 land recipients threatening legal action against the newly installed New Democratic Party (NDP) government, while the nation’s housing and land chief is urging patience as a review of the deals nears completion.

Housing and Land Management Minister Andrew John, speaking publicly during an interview with NBC Radio this Tuesday, addressed the growing tensions surrounding land parcels distributed by the previous Unity Labour Party (ULP) administration ahead of the last general election. The minister clarified that the current government has not moved to overturn all of the previous government’s land distribution decisions, but a full review of the process is required to ensure transparency and fairness.

The threatened lawsuit comes after the NDP government halted further payments from the 215 recipients toward their land purchases. Representing the affected claimants, lawyer Adrian Odle confirmed that his legal team has interviewed all 215 Vincentians, who have alleged discriminatory treatment and breach of contract by the current government. Odle also noted that recipients across the country holding formal land contracts have been informed that no additional down payments or installments will be accepted by the state.

John pushed back on the claims, questioning the circumstances of the last-minute land distribution that raised immediate red flags for his administration. He called the impending lawsuit “amusing”, arguing that the sheer volume of parcels allocated right before the election cycle, concentrated heavily in a single constituency, makes the original distribution politically questionable at face value. As a responsible governing body, the NDP has a binding obligation to audit the entire allocation process, the minister emphasized.

Data shared by John shows that out of all the pre-election land distributions, more than 150 parcels were allocated in North Windward constituency alone: 67 in Tourama and 91 in Langley Park. The minister noted that not all recipients are residents of North Windward, a fact that deepens concerns about the original distribution’s motives. He openly questioned whether the previous ULP administration deliberately pushed through the last-minute allocations to sway the election outcome in key competitive districts.

John pointed to a broader national context of land scarcity in St. Vincent and the Grenadines, with only North Windward and North Leeward holding surplus available land for distribution – parcels many citizens have historically avoided due to their proximity to the active La Soufrière volcano. Even so, all citizens deserve equal access to the limited available land, the minister said, which is why a full review is necessary.

Since taking office and assuming his full portfolio, which also covers urban development and informal settlement upgrading, John revealed that his department inherited no centralized list of people who had formally applied for land allocations. Thousands of Vincentians have been waiting years for land allocation responses, he said, yet many of the pre-election parcels went to applicants who had never gone through the standard formal application process.

John framed the threatened legal action as a move that will “open a can of worms” for recipients. Under the original land contract terms, purchasers have a 12-month window to complete required payments, a rule that has been widely ignored over the past 20 years, with thousands of people building homes on allocated land without fulfilling their payment obligations. If the lawsuit proceeds, the government will be forced to retroactively review all past breaches of contract, which could ultimately result in land being reclaimed from recipients who failed to meet their obligations – a route the current government has no desire to take, John said.

The minister stressed that the NDP administration has not notified any recipient that they will lose their land, even though the original allocations were approved via Cabinet memo, a document that can be reversed by a new Cabinet. He rejected claims that the government is targeting or victimizing land recipients, noting that the review is rooted in a commitment to equitable distribution for all Vincentians, including the many long-time applicants who have yet to receive any response from the government despite years of waiting.

“All we are asking is for some time to review, and the process is almost finished,” John reiterated, calling on affected recipients to wait for the outcome of the audit before moving forward with legal action.