LETTER: St. Augustine and Prostitution; Government and Abortion

A public statement from advocacy group ASPIRE has drawn on 1,500 years of established Christian theological thought to critique the paralyzed policy-making framework in St. John’s, arguing that local political leaders have failed to adopt a long-proven distinction between personal moral standards and evidence-based public policy. The statement anchors its argument in the teachings of two foundational pillars of Christian and Catholic theological thought: St. Augustine of Hippo, and his later influential successor St. Thomas Aquinas, who built much of his own scholarly work on Augustine’s foundational writings some 700 years after the earlier theologian’s death. Born in what is now modern-day Algeria during the era of Roman colonial rule, Augustine lived a life marked by open sexual promiscuity before converting to Christianity at the age of 33, drawing on that lived experience to shape his pragmatic framework for civil governance. In his seminal text *De Ordine*, Augustine laid out his reasoning rooted in the principle of the lesser evil: he explicitly condemned prostitution as morally abhorrent, sinful and ethically wrong, yet argued forcefully that civil governing bodies should formalize legal status and structured regulation for the practice. His core reasoning held that full criminalization and total prohibition of sex work would not eliminate the activity, but instead spawn far more widespread social harm, unregulated exploitation and widespread public disorder that would damage the broader community far more than carefully managed legal oversight. ASPIRE points out that centuries of subsequent peer-reviewed social science research have thoroughly validated Augustine’s centuries-old pragmatic insight, yet the current government in St. John’s remains trapped in a state of total policy paralysis, held back by unthinking, absolutist religious dogma that prioritizes rigid ideological edicts over the collective public good. The advocacy group emphasizes that the core, distinct roles of legislators and religious leaders have been dangerously blurred in current local governance. Elected lawmakers are tasked with drafting and implementing laws that serve the shared interests of all residents, drawing clear lines between legally permitted and prohibited conduct to maintain safe, functional communities. By contrast, the exclusive mandate of religious leaders is to guide their communities on questions of personal moral virtue, using persuasion and spiritual teaching to encourage followers to choose ethical conduct and avoid actions they deem immoral. ASPIRE argues that when religious persuasion fails to shift individual behavior, it is a fundamental overreach for faith leaders to pressure elected legislators to codify their private moral frameworks into binding public law. The group stresses that legislation can never foster genuine moral conduct at its core: at most, legal rules can coerce superficial public compliance, but true moral behavior can only emerge from uncoerced individual choice and the free exercise of personal conscience. The statement goes on to warn that local religious leaders have successfully instilled pervasive fear in St. John’s elected officials, and that deep-seated misogynistic currents running through many contemporary religious leadership circles drive a harmful obsession with controlling women’s bodily autonomy. This dynamic, ASPIRE concludes, has left local political leaders unwilling to take decisive, evidence-based action to avoid public controversy, leaving the collective public good to suffer disproportionately, with the harshest harms falling directly on women and girls across the region.