Chastanet joins regional opposition leaders challenging CBI secrecy

A cross-national bloc of five opposition leaders across the Eastern Caribbean has issued a unified public call demanding that regional administrations fully disclose all positions, formal commitments, and ongoing negotiation details shared with the European Union regarding the bloc’s push to phase out longstanding Citizenship by Investment (CBI) schemes. The coordinated advocacy is spearheaded by Saint Lucia’s opposition leader Allen Chastanet, alongside Grenada’s opposition head Adrian Joseph, Antigua and Barbuda opposition leader Jamale Pringle, St Kitts and Nevis People’s Action Movement chief Shawn Richards, and Dominica United Workers Party leader Thomson Fontaine.

The collective statement comes on the heels of a November 12 deadline that required all Eastern Caribbean governments to submit their formal stances on the future of CBI frameworks to EU authorities. At present, Saint Lucia’s Prime Minister Philip J. Pierre has maintained that his administration will not release the full contents of its formal response letter until it receives official feedback from the EU, even as he has publicly emphasized the CBI program’s critical local economic value. During a pre-Cabinet media briefing earlier this week, Pierre noted that the scheme directly employs over 30 local residents, generates significant public revenue, and that Saint Lucia will chart its own independent negotiating path rather than mirroring decisions made by neighboring regional states, adding that the country will prolong talks with the EU to safeguard its national interests.

The five opposition heads acknowledged that two regional governments have already publicly laid out their CBI plans: St Kitts and Nevis has announced it will wind down its program according to a mutually agreed negotiated timeline, while Antigua and Barbuda has signaled it will pursue the same phase-out but push for an extended transition window. However, the group stressed that all remaining regional administrations have a fundamental duty to their electorates to reveal the full terms of any commitments already conveyed to EU counterparts.

To ensure full democratic accountability, the opposition coalition is demanding that sitting governments deliver formal public statements on their CBI negotiation status during parliamentary sessions, laying out their official EU response, all binding commitments made to date, proposed phase-out timelines, and unresolved points of contention still on the negotiating table. They are also requesting that opposition legislative representatives receive confidential, closed-door briefings on sensitive classified elements of the talks where necessary.

The group raised urgent, unaddressed concerns over cascading economic risks tied to the ongoing deliberations, citing recent warnings from St Kitts and Nevis Prime Minister Dr Terrance Drew that changes to CBI status could trigger a collapse of critical regional correspondent banking relationships. Such a disruption, the leaders warned, would cripple core national financial lifelines including cross-border remittances, import payment processing, tourism revenue transfers, and other high-priority international commercial transactions. They are calling on governments to immediately clarify whether formal, concrete threats have been issued by foreign regulators, EU authorities, or active correspondent banking partners, and to clearly separate verified, imminent risks from speculative, hypothetical scenarios. The coalition is also pushing for a coordinated risk assessment run in partnership with the Eastern Caribbean Central Bank and the entire regional banking sector, paired with pre-planned contingency measures to shield ordinary households and small businesses from potential financial disruption.

Additionally, the opposition bloc has pushed back against unsubstantiated official narratives that frame the loss of visa-free travel access to the EU as an automatic precursor to the collapse of correspondent banking partnerships, urging administrations to avoid conflating separate policy outcomes. The leaders are also demanding a full, independent financial audit of all CBI-linked revenue streams and expenditure patterns, to map all public funds tied to the programs, track balances in associated dedicated funds, and catalog outstanding contractual obligations to private developers and public infrastructure projects. This audit, they argue, is a necessary step to clarify how core public services and ongoing construction projects will be fully financed if CBI revenue streams shrink or are eliminated entirely.

The five opposition leaders are advocating for a unified, coordinated regional negotiating position that centers the public’s best interests, addresses legitimate EU security concerns tied to CBI participant vetting, and secures a fair, structured transition framework paired with targeted EU development assistance and viable long-term sustainable investment alternatives to replace CBI revenue. They are also calling for strict, mandatory safeguards to be enforced across all jurisdictions during any transition period, including rigorous ongoing due diligence for remaining CBI applicants, fully transparent public accounting for all program funds, and independent third-party oversight. The group issued a specific warning against last-minute, rushed CBI approvals or new unvetted contractual commitments that could leave ordinary local taxpayers on the hook for unfunded liabilities once the programs are discontinued.

To support a smooth, equitable shift away from CBI revenue dependence, the coalition is also pushing for the co-development of a credible, inclusive economic transition plan drafted in partnership with private sector representatives, worker advocacy groups, and civil society organizations, designed to expand productive domestic investment, create stable local employment, and build diversified, long-term sustainable streams of government revenue. While the five opposition leaders acknowledged that CBI programs have delivered tangible development benefits across the Eastern Caribbean in past decades, they emphasized that these gains must be weighed against the well-documented risks of excessive economic dependence on the schemes, as well as the rapidly shifting global regulatory environment for citizenship-by-investment frameworks.

Finally, the group issued a direct appeal to the European Union to approach the ongoing negotiations in a collaborative, partnership-focused spirit, taking full account of the unique economic vulnerabilities of small island developing states, and rolling out practical, concrete financial support to replace the CBI revenue streams the EU is requesting regional governments to relinquish. The leaders noted that their respective opposition parties stand ready to participate constructively in the national and regional deliberation processes, but stressed that sitting administrations must first release the full scope of relevant information to enable meaningful, informed public and legislative engagement.