LaRoda: campaign donations not illegal in The Bahamas

Top Bahamian national security official Myles LaRoda, whose portfolio exercises administrative oversight over the Parliamentary Registration Department that manages all national electoral operations, has refused to issue a formal position on explosive court claims that $30,000 in cash carried by Bahamian figure Jonathan “Player” Gardiner on the 2024 general election day was earmarked for campaign-related contributions and expenditures. In public remarks, LaRoda clarified he had not yet reviewed the full set of recent filings submitted in a New York federal court, and stated he could not weigh in on specific unsubstantiated allegations without access to verified, complete factual background.

The novel explanation for Gardiner’s large Election Day cash haul was laid out in a formal court reply filed by his legal counsel Susy Ribero-Ayala, who argued the funds were designated for legitimate campaign costs as Gardiner traveled across multiple Bahamian islands to coordinate with voters and campaign staff. The defense team has explicitly rejected U.S. prosecutors’ framing of the cash as illicit drug proceeds or a narcotics-linked bribe, even addressing a specific $5,000 envelope marked with a sitting politician’s handwritten name. Ribero-Ayala emphasized that the presence of a politician’s name on the envelope, paired with the timing of the cash transfer, cannot on its own be interpreted as proof the funds were tied to narcotics activity, when weighed against the defense’s full contextual explanation and the way the cash was packaged. Notably, the defense filing does not specify which political campaign was slated to receive the funds, nor does it detail the exact nature of the planned campaign expenditures.

U.S. prosecuting attorneys have pushed back against this framing, noting that Gardiner chose to carry the full $30,000 sum on Election Day itself, rather than during the weeks of official pre-election campaigning. Court filings describe the politician whose name appears on the envelope as a male incumbent Member of Parliament who won re-election on that same May 12 polling date; the individual has not been publicly named or charged with any offense to date.

To corroborate their claim that the cash was legally sourced, Gardiner’s legal team submitted a Bank of The Bahamas receipt documenting a $20,000 withdrawal from Top Notch Builders Limited dated May 11, 2024 — exactly one day before the general election. Public records show Top Notch Builders has been awarded millions of dollars in government contracts during successive administrations led by the Progressive Liberal Party (PLP), and corporate filings list Gardiner as the company’s president for the 2016 and 2017 calendar years.

The Bahamas currently operates with no formal national campaign finance legislation on the books, meaning political parties face no mandatory legal requirements to disclose the identities of their financial backers, the total sum of donations they receive, or how those funds are allocated for campaign activities. While no laws explicitly ban campaign contributions entirely, the existing Parliamentary Elections Act does draw a clear legal line around Election Day activities: offering or lending money to any voter in exchange for casting or withholding a vote is classified as electoral bribery, a corrupt practice punishable by up to two years of imprisonment, a $2,000 fine, and a seven-year ban from both voting and running for public office. The same statute explicitly exempts the provision of free transport to and from polling stations via land, sea, or air from classification as an illegal election practice.

The high-profile case first came to public attention on May 12, 2024, when a small aircraft carrying Gardiner from Marsh Harbour, Abaco, to Grand Bahama crashed off the coast of Florida. Other passengers on the flight were identified as PLP supporters traveling to Grand Bahama to cast their ballots; 11 people on board were rescued, and all other passengers were permitted to leave the scene, while Gardiner was taken into U.S. federal custody. The 58-year-old Gardiner previously served a U.S. prison sentence in 2008 for his involvement in an international drug trafficking conspiracy, and he has entered a not guilty plea in the New York federal case to charges of conspiring to import cocaine, possessing firearms in furtherance of drug trafficking, and conspiring to possess firearms. His formal trial is scheduled to commence on March 1, 2025. U.S. federal authorities further allege that the unnamed incumbent MP referred to in court documents only as “Politician-1” met with an undercover DEA source and a drug transport pilot inside a Bahamian Parliament building in October 2024 to finalize arrangements for a large cocaine shipment.

The case has reignited long-simmering public debate over campaign finance transparency in the Bahamas. During the June 2024 national budget debate, Long Island MP Andre Rollins formally asked parliamentary colleagues whether Gardiner had made any financial donations to PLP electoral campaigns, but no PLP member rose to offer a public response. The official post-election observation report released by CARICOM’s independent election monitoring team in August 2024 highlighted the complete absence of campaign finance regulation in the Bahamas, and put forward a slate of concrete recommendations: mandatory public disclosure of all political party funding sources, legally enforced caps on campaign spending, and robust, meaningful penalties for vote buying and the misuse of state resources for campaign purposes. While the observer team noted that multiple electoral stakeholders had reported anecdotal allegations of vote buying, the group did not find verifiable evidence that such practices had occurred on a systemic scale. The CARICOM team also recommended that the Parliamentary Registration Department be restructured into a fully independent election management body, a reform that National Security Minister LaRoda had previously publicly endorsed during earlier public remarks. Attorney General Wayne Munroe pushed back on portions of the CARICOM recommendations, arguing that existing Bahamian legal statutes already fully cover offenses related to vote buying and improper election-related favor-trading.

Despite repeated public campaign promises from both of the Bahamas’ major political parties to introduce comprehensive campaign finance reform, no successive administration has ever followed through to implement such legislation. The current Davis-led PLP administration has previously stated that advancing campaign finance rules is not a policy priority during its first term in office.