‘Hit back’ advice undermines conflict resolution, Antigua and Barbuda education minister says

During a recent appearance on the popular local Browne and Browne talk show, Antigua and Barbuda’s Minister of Education Daryll Matthew launched a firm rebuke of a pervasive, widely circulated piece of parental guidance that encourages children to physically retaliate if they are struck by a peer or other individual. Speaking as part of a targeted panel discussion focused on surging youth violence trends across the nation, Matthew labeled the directive of “if anyone hits you, knock them back” as one of the most harmful, counterproductive pieces of advice caregivers can impart to young people, noting it completely abandons any framework for constructive conflict resolution.

The minister was careful to clarify that his stance does not advocate for children to remain passive and accept physical harm without seeking help, but emphasized that responding to violence with equal or greater force carries a severe risk of turning minor altercations into dangerous, life-threatening escalations. “If you fight fire with fire, everybody gets burned,” Matthew warned, framing the cycle of retaliation as a public safety threat that harms all parties involved, rather than delivering any meaningful sense of protection or justice for young people.

Matthew positioned his comments as part of a broader, urgent policy push to reframe the conversation around student-related violence, rejecting the longstanding narrative that such incidents are the sole responsibility of school administrators to address. Instead, he argued that sustainable solutions must be rooted in coordinated action across households and local community networks. The minister acknowledged that many families face significant structural barriers to fulfilling this role, including widespread economic precarity that forces large numbers of parents to work multiple low-wage jobs, leaving children unsupervised for extended stretches of time after school and on weekends.

To close these gaps, Matthew called for expanded, accessible family support initiatives led by local civil society groups, including targeted parenting skill-building workshops hosted by faith communities, civic service clubs, and youth-focused nonprofits. He stressed that these outreach programs must intentionally engage both mothers and fathers, and prioritize proactive intervention for at-risk households before minor disagreements escalate into violent confrontations. The minister’s public remarks came on the heels of widespread public outcry over a viral social media video that captured a brutal physical altercation between a group of young people, prompting renewed calls for cross-sector action. Matthew noted that all violent assault incidents occurring outside of official school grounds fall under the jurisdiction of local law enforcement, while educational institutions retain a clear, vested interest in implementing safeguards to protect both their student bodies and staff from spillover community violence.