Antigua and Barbuda’s Attorney General Sir Steadroy “Cutie” Benjamin has ignited a constitutional debate by questioning whether the nation’s Senate remains necessary for effective governance. During parliamentary proceedings on Tuesday, Benjamin challenged longstanding political structures, suggesting the country should consider transitioning to a single-chamber parliamentary system.
The senior legal official contrasted the theoretical role of upper chambers with Caribbean realities, noting that while senates in systems like Britain’s serve to review legislation and provide corrective guidance, this ideal has not materialized in the regional context. “In the Caribbean, it is not exactly the case,” Benjamin observed, referencing regional discussions about eliminating senates entirely, as occurred in Dominica.
Benjamin’s remarks form part of a comprehensive push for constitutional modernization that has been delayed for decades. He emphasized that no institution should be immune from scrutiny in serious constitutional reviews, framing the issue as one of national maturity rather than partisan politics. While not explicitly calling for immediate abolition, the Attorney General made clear that the Senate’s relevance and functionality warrant thorough examination.
This Senate debate occurs alongside other proposed constitutional changes, including transitioning to a republic status, modifying oaths of allegiance, and acceding to the Caribbean Court of Justice. Benjamin urged Parliament to initiate formal discussions under constitutional reform provisions, asserting that the time has come for proper review of the nation’s foundational document.