The Caribbean Court of Justice (CCJ) has definitively dismissed an appeal by Opposition Leader Allen Chastanet, marking the end of a protracted legal battle involving customs charges against Deputy Prime Minister Dr. Ernest Hilaire. The ruling, issued on October 15, 2025, reaffirms prior decisions by Saint Lucia’s High Court and Court of Appeal, both of which had rejected Chastanet’s challenge to the withdrawal of the charges.
The case originated in 2020 when the Comptroller of Customs filed charges against Hilaire under the Customs (Control and Management) Act. The allegations centered on the purported illegal importation of a Land Rover Discovery vehicle following Hilaire’s tenure as Saint Lucia’s High Commissioner in London. In 2021, the newly appointed Comptroller of Customs, Sharman Emmanuel, sought and obtained permission from the Magistrates’ Court to withdraw the case, effectively terminating the proceedings.
Chastanet contested this decision, arguing that the Director of Public Prosecutions (DPP) had assumed control of the case by the time it was withdrawn, thereby stripping the Comptroller of the authority to end it. However, the CCJ rejected this argument, stating that there was no concrete evidence to support the claim that the DPP had formally taken over the prosecution. The court emphasized that merely forwarding the case file to the DPP and the involvement of DPP counsel in the proceedings did not constitute a formal takeover.
Furthermore, the CCJ clarified that the magistrate’s decision to grant the withdrawal superseded the Comptroller’s administrative action. As such, any legal challenge should have been directed at the magistrate’s ruling rather than the Comptroller’s initial request. The court concluded that Chastanet’s judicial review of the Comptroller’s decision was legally flawed, bringing the case to a final and irrevocable close. This ruling underscores the lawful execution of the charges’ withdrawal and affirms the integrity of the judicial process.