A devastating fatal car crash on Shirley Street in the Bahamas has left four teenage girls dead, and now their heartbroken families are demanding urgent accountability and criminal charges against the 19-year-old driver who survived the collision. Among the grieving relatives is Damien Stubbs, father of 17-year-old victim Diamond Stubbs, who says his sympathy for the young driver completely evaporated after a viral video filmed in the driver’s hospital room spread across social media.
The tragic collision on Sunday claimed the lives of Diamond Stubbs, 18-year-old Betrica Brown, 19-year-old Stania Webb, and 19-year-old Evalena Johnson. Three of the four victims grew up together on Cat Island, and the driver was part of the same tight-knit local community, with deep personal ties to all of the deceased. According to Stubbs, he has known the driver since he was a small child, and their families have long been close.
The widely circulated social media video shows the 19-year-old driver recovering in a hospital bed with a cast on his wrist. When prompted by the person recording, the driver turns toward the camera and smiles, a moment that has sparked widespread condemnation from the public and the victims’ families alike. For Stubbs, this footage was the final breaking point in his grief.
Stubbs, who was preparing to send his daughter — a recent high school valedictorian and head girl — off to college this month, rejected an unverified apology letter circulating online that claimed to come from people featured in the video. He revealed that the driver’s family has not reached out to offer condolences since the crash, even noting that he shared a flight from Cat Island to New Providence with the driver’s father immediately after learning of the tragedy. Stubbs said he hugged the man before boarding, believing he had also lost a child, only learning later that his son had survived.
“What am I supposed to do right now? I was supposed to be taking my daughter to college this month, not laying her in a graveyard,” Stubbs said in an interview. “He was my daughter’s friend. If he doesn’t care about my child, what kind of friend does that make him? He should never have played along with that insensitive video in the hospital when four of his friends were dead.”
Other family members have echoed Stubbs’ anger and shock at the video. Betrica Brown’s aunt, Densandria Wright, called the footage “a punch in the gut”, saying the incident has left her questioning the emotional awareness of today’s younger generation. Betrica, who recently earned a college volleyball scholarship, had her whole life ahead of her, and her family says their only focus now is securing justice. Anthony Thompson, who raised Betrica from the age of nine after their mother passed away, said he cannot fathom how the driver could appear so unbothered after the crash. “Four people died while he was behind the wheel. If that were me, that would torment me for the rest of my life,” Thompson said.
Bahamas Attorney General Wayne Munroe addressed the case this week, confirming that authorities are currently reviewing whether criminal charges are appropriate following the fatal collision. Under Bahamian law, all unnatural deaths are subject to a coroner’s inquest unless criminal charges are filed first. Munroe noted that possible offenses under consideration range from dangerous driving causing death down to careless driving, depending on the findings of the ongoing investigation.
Across the Bahamas, public condemnation of the video has grown, with many residents saying the footage demonstrates a clear lack of remorse for the four young lives cut short. For the victims’ families, no outcome will ever bring their loved ones back. “Whatever sentence he gets, he will eventually get out of jail. But my daughter is going to be in the ground forever,” Stubbs said.









