In a landmark decision, the Privy Council has upheld a 2023 Court of Appeal ruling in favor of Calder Hart, former chairman of Udecott, affirming that he was denied natural justice during the 2016 Las Alturas commission of enquiry (CoE). The commission had blamed Hart for the collapse of the Morvant housing project, but the Privy Council, led by Lord Clark and supported by Lords Sales, Leggatt, Lady Rose, and Lady Simler, ruled on October 30 that the commission breached Hart’s right to procedural fairness by publishing adverse findings without allowing him to respond. The judges emphasized that natural justice requires individuals to be given the opportunity to defend themselves against criticism, a principle that was violated in Hart’s case. The commission’s findings, which held Hart personally accountable for the project’s failure, were quashed, as they were deemed to have been arrived at in breach of natural justice. The Las Alturas project, plagued by landslides and structural failures, resulted in significant public losses and the demolition of two apartment buildings. The Privy Council’s ruling underscores the importance of fairness in judicial processes, regardless of an individual’s participation in an inquiry. The commission’s appeal, arguing that Hart had declined to participate and that fairness did not require prior notice, was dismissed. The Privy Council also rejected the commission’s claim that extending the inquiry to allow Hart to respond would have been inappropriate, stating that the seriousness of the findings demanded prior warning. This ruling reaffirms the fundamental principle that no one should be condemned unheard.
分类: society
-

Hanover reels from Melissa’s devastating impact
The Noel Holmes Hospital in Hanover, Jamaica, has sustained significant damage following the devastating impact of Hurricane Melissa, which struck the southwest of the island before moving across its western end on Tuesday. During a visit by the Jamaica Observer, it was observed that several key sections of the hospital, including the maternity ward, dietary department, and administrative block, had their roofs severely compromised. Despite the destruction, hospital staff demonstrated remarkable resilience, continuing to perform their duties, such as preparing meals and attending to patients, while also addressing the aftermath by clearing water and mopping floors in the dietary department. The nearby Hanover Health Department also suffered roof damage, further exacerbating the crisis. The hurricane’s wrath extended beyond healthcare facilities, causing widespread infrastructural devastation across the parish. Numerous buildings lost their roofs entirely or partially, while fallen trees and power lines obstructed several roads. Communication networks were severely disrupted, leaving many residents unable to make calls or access the internet. Some individuals reportedly traveled to Montego Bay to use their mobile phones for communication. Additionally, downed utility poles led to widespread electricity outages, and a section of the Sandy Bay Main Road sea wall collapsed, causing the sidewalk to cave in. The community of Hanover now faces the daunting task of recovery and rebuilding in the wake of this natural disaster.
-

#MelissaAftermath: Trelawny police clear fallen trees after ‘devastating impact’ in parish
In the aftermath of Hurricane Melissa, Trelawny, Jamaica, witnessed a significant police presence on Wednesday as officers worked tirelessly to clear the extensive damage left by the storm. A dedicated team of 30 police personnel, under the leadership of Superintendent Velonique Campbell, took to the streets armed with chainsaws and machetes to remove fallen trees that had obstructed major roadways.
-

US-based Forbes Family Foundation to deliver hurricane relief to Westmoreland and St Elizabeth
Residents of St Elizabeth and Westmoreland, severely affected by Hurricane Melissa, are set to receive critical relief through the efforts of the Forbes Family Foundation, a U.S.-based non-profit organization. Founded by Dr. Ariel Forbes, a Jamaican-born oral surgeon, the foundation has outlined a comprehensive two-phase plan to aid recovery in the impacted regions. The first phase focuses on immediate support, including the distribution of essential supplies such as water, canned goods, generators, solar power banks, clothing, and cleaning materials. The second phase will address long-term recovery, providing construction materials like drywall, cement, tiles, and power tools to rebuild damaged homes. Dr. Forbes emphasized the urgency of the situation, noting that food tents will be established in Black River, St Elizabeth, and either Darliston or Whitehouse, Westmoreland, to serve hot meals to those in need. Despite initial flight cancellations, Dr. Forbes is scheduled to arrive in Jamaica on November 12, with supplies already en route via sea freight. The foundation is seeking logistical support to transport these items from Kingston to the affected parishes. Motivated by her Jamaican heritage and personal ties to the region, Dr. Forbes expressed her commitment to helping communities recover from the devastation. The Forbes Family Foundation has also launched a fundraiser to support these relief efforts, underscoring their dedication to rebuilding lives and restoring hope in the wake of Hurricane Melissa.
-

Misery amplified
Residents of Portland Cottage, Jamaica, are voicing their frustration over what they perceive as systemic neglect in disaster relief efforts following the devastation caused by Hurricane Melissa. Many of these individuals, already living in dire poverty, claim they have yet to receive any assistance from previous hurricanes, including Hurricane Beryl in July. Despite registering for aid and providing necessary documentation, they say their pleas have fallen on deaf ears. Dennis Baju, a resident of Dry Hill, lamented, ‘No help, no help, none a di storm dem weh blow. This a go meck the seventh storm and wi don’t get no help.’ His 87-year-old mother, Gloria, who was forced to relocate her small business into her one-bedroom home after Beryl destroyed her shop’s roof, accused political players of discrimination. ‘Is victimisation. When them come fi give food is down dah way deh it go,’ she said. Similar grievances were echoed by other residents, including Neville Gayle, whose home was severely damaged by Melissa. ‘Mi woulda like some zinc fi meck up back mi bathroom and di roof,’ he said while attempting to clean his muddied, decrepit structure. The community’s frustration is compounded by the perception that relief efforts are politicized, with aid allegedly directed toward certain areas or individuals based on political affiliations. ‘Dem [disaster relief personnel] nah go come yah now, dem specialise inna politics,’ one young woman remarked. Despite the hardships, some residents remain resilient, expressing gratitude for their survival. ‘Mi glad mi alive and mi family an mi grandpickney dem alive,’ one woman said. As the community begins the arduous task of rebuilding, the calls for equitable and timely assistance grow louder, with many urging authorities to address the systemic issues plaguing disaster relief distribution.
-

In the heart of the rainforest
The Asa Wright Nature Centre, nestled in Trinidad’s Northern Range rainforest, stands as a timeless sanctuary for nature enthusiasts and researchers alike. Dr. Anjani Ganase, a marine scientist, reflects on her transformative experiences at the Centre, which played a pivotal role in shaping her career and deepening her connection to Trinidad’s natural heritage. Her journey began as an undergraduate volunteer for the Guppy Project, led by Dr. David Reznik, where she explored the Arima-Blanchisseuse Valley’s river ecosystems. Despite the challenges of fieldwork—mosquito bites, muddy trails, and Deet mishaps—the experience ignited her passion for environmental science. Later, as a volunteer for the Asa Wright Educational Programme, she contributed to drafting grant applications and leading educational outreach initiatives, fostering a deeper appreciation for the Centre’s ecological richness. The Centre’s vibrant biodiversity, from toucans and bellbirds to nocturnal wildlife like scorpions and porcupines, continues to captivate visitors. Dr. Ganase’s recent return to the Centre, now revitalized by Hadco Experiences, reaffirmed its enduring charm and significance. She hopes that locals and visitors, especially children from the Arima-Blanchisseuse Valley, will experience this tropical haven at least once in their lives.
-

‘We need help’
The aftermath of Category 5 Hurricane Melissa has left several communities in St Elizabeth, Jamaica, in a state of despair, with residents marooned and first responders struggling to access the hardest-hit areas. The storm, which struck on Tuesday, has caused widespread destruction, leaving roads impassable, homes destroyed, and communication lines severed.
-

MYSTIC THAI for World Central Kitchen
As Hurricane Melissa approached Jamaica, Mystic Thai, a local restaurant, joined forces with the humanitarian organization World Central Kitchen (WCK) to prepare and distribute meals to homes, shelters, and community centers across the island. The collaboration began well before the storm’s landfall, ensuring that hot meals would be available immediately after the hurricane passed. By October 28, the teams had already delivered meals to four locations, including the National Arena, a day prior to the storm’s arrival. The final batch of meals was distributed early on Tuesday, October 28. WCK emphasized its coordination with local restaurant partners to guarantee meal availability post-hurricane. Mystic Thai’s team worked tirelessly, preparing comforting dishes like chicken curry with rice and salad, which were staged for delivery even as storm shutters were being installed. The restaurant’s directors expressed gratitude for the partnership, highlighting its role in serving vulnerable populations, particularly families in shelters and those displaced by the storm. The joint effort leveraged Mystic Thai’s kitchen and staff alongside WCK’s logistical expertise. As relief operations intensify, Mystic Thai and WCK will continue assessing food needs in affected communities, replenishing kitchens, and adapting meal distribution routes if roads or power are disrupted. This initiative reflects the broader spirit of community resilience in Jamaica, where local businesses and international organizations work together to ensure no one goes without a hot meal during recovery. The effort has garnered recognition, with chefs like James Beard award-winner Andrew Black and Roger Mooking expressing support. Those wishing to contribute to Jamaica’s recovery can do so via supportjamaica.gov.jm.
-

King Charles to strip Andrew of royal titles
In a significant move, King Charles III has officially stripped his younger brother, Prince Andrew, of his royal titles and privileges. The decision, announced by the palace on Thursday, marks a dramatic shift in the royal family’s handling of the ongoing controversy surrounding Prince Andrew. The statement declared, ‘His Majesty has today initiated a formal process to remove the Style, Titles and Honours of Prince Andrew.’ Consequently, Prince Andrew will now be referred to as Andrew Mountbatten Windsor, a clear departure from his previous royal status. Additionally, he will vacate his long-standing residence within the grounds of Windsor Castle. This decision comes in the wake of renewed public outrage over allegations made by one of Jeffrey Epstein’s primary accusers, which Prince Andrew has consistently denied. The palace’s action underscores the monarchy’s efforts to distance itself from the scandal and maintain its public image.
-

So close, but so far
In the wake of Hurricane Melissa’s devastating passage through Jamaica, communication systems collapsed, leaving countless families isolated and desperate for news of their loved ones. On Wednesday, Jamaicans from across the island, including some from as far as Kingston, flocked to St Elizabeth in a determined effort to locate their relatives and assess the damage to their properties. The journey was fraught with challenges, as downed trees and power lines turned what should have been a 15-minute drive into a grueling five-hour ordeal. Among the travelers was an amputee known as ‘One Foot Carl,’ who, armed with a power saw and gasoline, joined a slow-moving caravan of vehicles to help clear the roads. Supported by his crutches, Carl worked alongside Jamaica Defence Force soldiers to remove blockades, demonstrating remarkable resilience in the face of adversity. Another traveler, Jerome Steadman, made light of the situation, joking about his sister sharing the hurricane’s name. Despite a flat tire, Steadman remained undeterred in his mission to check on his home in Kingston, which he feared had been flattened by the storm. Stefan Wisdom, traveling with his infant son and Steadman, was also on a mission to salvage what remained of his house, which a friend had reported as destroyed. In Lacovia, residents recounted their harrowing experiences of battling the hurricane to preserve their lives and property. Mario White, who sheltered behind a single sheet of zinc for three hours, described how the storm forced him to retreat with his TV and medication as everything around him began to lift off. Omar Perry, another Lacovia resident, fought tirelessly to keep his front door from blowing off, only to find his partner’s shop flattened and carried across the road by the storm. Despite his exhaustion, Perry was determined to rebuild his roof to provide shelter for his family. Shantalea Kerr and her brother Shawn, who had evacuated their home fearing the storm’s strength, returned to find their family house leaning to the side, its roof gone. Shawn, who had sought refuge in a car during the storm, recounted how the wind had flipped open the car’s bonnet, cracking the windscreen. Despite the overwhelming destruction, the residents of St Elizabeth remained resolute, refusing to abandon their journey to access other affected areas like Holland Bamboo and Black River. Their determination and resilience in the face of such devastation serve as a testament to the indomitable spirit of the Jamaican people.
