OPINION: Flow and Digicel can sell you 1 GBPS for less but the government says no

Residents of Antigua and Barbuda are being locked out of affordable, ultra-high-speed broadband access that neighboring Caribbean nations already enjoy, due to restrictive government telecom regulations that bar major private internet service providers (ISPs) Flow and Digicel from deploying modern fiber-to-the-home infrastructure, a new analysis reveals.
Economic data from 2024 highlights the stark disparity across the Eastern Caribbean: Antigua and Barbuda boasts a per capita GDP of $23,726 across its 100,000 residents, nearly 66% higher than Dominica’s $14,300 per capita GDP for its 73,449-person population. Yet Flow, which offers symmetric 1Gbps fiber broadband as a standard, low-cost residential offering to all ordinary citizens in Dominica, is unable to deliver speeds faster than 50Mbps to most of its Antigua and Barbuda customer base. The same arbitrary speed caps apply to competing provider Digicel, despite both firms having the technical capacity to roll out far faster service at lower price points for local households.
The root of this discrepancy, industry observers point out, is a decades-old 1951 colonial-era telecom rule set that the current Antigua and Barbuda government has retained to grant a near-exclusive fiber deployment monopoly to state-owned utility APUA Inet. Private ISPs Flow and Digicel are legally prohibited from leveraging modern fiber optic technology, which is the only viable infrastructure to deliver multi-gigabit residential speeds at affordable rates. Instead, regulators force the two private carriers to operate exclusively on limited-capacity wireless networks, which have inherent bandwidth constraints and far higher operational costs that make 1Gbps service impractical for mass consumer rollout. Critics compare this policy to permanently trapping ISPs in the dial-up internet era, long after the rest of the region has moved to full fiber broadband.
This regulatory imbalance creates a deeply unlevel competitive playing field: locked out of fiber upgrades, Flow and Digicel have seen large swathes of their customer base defect to APUA Inet, which is the only local provider permitted to offer 100Mbps fiber service. Even with its state-granted monopoly advantage, however, APUA’s broadband offerings still lag far behind the speed and affordability of Flow’s consumer packages in lower-income Dominica. The policy has also saddled Antigua and Barbuda’s taxpayers with massive public debt to fund APUA’s fiber network expansion, while actively blocking Flow and Digicel – two major private employers and top corporate tax contributors that pay far more in income and windfall taxes than any smaller local telecom operator – from making their own private capital investments in the local digital economy at a time when youth unemployment remains a pressing national concern.
Regulatory missteps have created a cascade of unintended negative economic consequences as well. Local consumers fed up with slow, expensive domestic broadband are increasingly turning to Starlink satellite internet, a foreign-owned provider that is permitted to operate with no bandwidth caps and no requirement to invest in local physical infrastructure. This shift is draining critical foreign exchange reserves out of the national economy, as Starlink repatriates nearly all its profits overseas with no obligation to reinvest in local jobs or digital infrastructure, unlike Flow and Digicel. The policy has also eroded the government’s own tax revenue base, as declining subscriber numbers for local ISPs – including APUA – put existing local telecom jobs at risk, even as the Ministry of Telecom claims the restrictive rules create a new dedicated revenue stream for the state.
Critics slam the policy as legally enabled by outdated colonial legacy rules, the same framework previously deployed to seize communal land from Barbudan residents, that lack any modern public interest justification. Advocates note that United Nations research has repeatedly confirmed that universal access to high-speed fiber broadband is a core driver of national economic development, educational advancement, and small business growth. They are now calling on Antigua and Barbuda residents to organize and demand regulatory reform, to scrap the unfair 1951 telecom restrictions and allow all licensed ISPs to compete on a level playing field to deliver affordable multi-gigabit broadband to every household.