MONTEGO BAY, St James — A fatal early-morning police operation on the outskirts of Montego Bay has reignited long-simmering tensions over law enforcement use of force, after four men were shot dead Wednesday in an incident that has left grieving relatives crying foul and authorities defending the action as a necessary step to curb growing community violence.
Patterns of conflicting narratives that have become all too familiar in Jamaican fatal police shootings are playing out once again: bereaved family members are adamant the men were unarmed workers carrying out their jobs, pointing to unprovoked excessive force as the cause of death, while official police accounts frame the incident as a targeted operation that devolved into an armed shootout with suspects tied to a wave of local violence. What makes this incident unusual is the sheer loss of life in a single confrontation.
The victims have been identified as Jahmar Ashman, 57-year-old Brian “Teezy” Fairclough, Brian’s son Brian “Teejay” Fairclough, and a fourth man who remains unidentified as of press time. The shooting unfolded at a marl quarry near the Retirement Dump area, according to official records.
For Tameika Evans, partner of Jahmar Ashman, the tragedy has left her struggling to explain the loss to the couple’s two-year-old child, who remains unaware his father is dead. The toddler was seen eating candy near the crime scene Wednesday as police maintained a secured cordon around the area. Evans told local media the Jamaica Observer that Ashman and the younger Fairclough worked as night watchmen at the quarry. She received word of the shooting from her mother, who first noted a heavy police presence in the area, and law enforcement had already transported the bodies to hospital before Evans could arrive on scene.
Near the crime scene, Tashoy Fairclough, the newly widowed wife of Brian Fairclough, told reporters she is terrified of the long-term impact her husband’s death will have on their two young children. The couple’s 10-year-old daughter is scheduled to sit her Primary Exit Profile (PEP) national exit exams Wednesday, and Fairclough said the child has been inconsolable, unable to focus on the test despite school officials arranging support. “All of this is police brutality; them a wicked and we need justice round here suh,” Fairclough said. She explained her husband worked as a tractor operator at the quarry and had been staying on site in a quarry building with his son and the two other men at the time of the raid. She described him as a peaceable man who avoided conflict.
Gwendolyn Williams, who raised Brian “Teejay” Fairclough from infancy, echoed the family’s anger and worry. She said none of the four men deserved to die, and expressed concern that the young children left behind will now be forced to survive without their breadwinners. “Them dead and leave them little children to go to school, them shouldn’t kill them. They didn’t do the police nothing fi them kill them,” Williams insisted.
But the Jamaica Constabulary Force (JCF) has pushed back against the claims, releasing an official statement outlining the context for the operation. According to the JCF, the operation was launched at approximately 5:40 a.m. Wednesday based on intelligence gathered during ongoing investigations into a recent string of violent incidents in the area, including a fatal shooting at the Retirement Dump on June 5. Investigators have linked multiple violent attacks to an ongoing turf conflict between groups involved in the local scrap metal trade operating out of the dump.
The JCF statement noted that long-standing disputes between scrap metal and recyclable material collectors and sellers had escalated in recent weeks, triggering a cycle of violent reprisal attacks that pushed community tensions to dangerous levels. Wednesday’s targeted raid was designed to prevent further bloodshed, the force said, adding that intelligence indicated additional attacks were imminent. “Law enforcement personnel were deployed to the area as part of ongoing efforts to disrupt criminal activity, prevent additional loss of life, and restore public safety,” the statement read. All four men shot during the confrontation were transported to hospital, where they were subsequently pronounced dead, according to the JCF.
Consistent with standard protocol for all fatal shootings involving Jamaica Constabulary Force members, the Independent Commission of Investigations (Indecom) has launched an independent probe into the incident.
This fatal shooting marks the fourth high-profile incident involving fatalities during security force operations in Granville division since the start of 2024. On New Year’s Day, a four-year-old child and two adult men were killed during a police operation in the same community. On Mother’s Day, 17-year-old Tjey Edwards was fatally shot during an alleged confrontation with law enforcement. One week after Edwards’ death, Latoya “Buju” Bulgin was shot and killed by Constable Andrew Wilson while she was transporting people to a protest over Edwards’ death. The officer has since been charged with Bulgin’s murder and is currently awaiting trial.
Indecom data shows the scale of growing fatal confrontations in the country: 14 people have been killed in alleged clashes with security forces across Jamaica since the start of June. Eleven of those deaths occurred between Tuesday and Wednesday of this week, including two separate quadruple fatal shootings.