A cross-Caribbean manhunt that spanned years reached a key milestone this Tuesday, as 33-year-old Jamaican national Orville Andrew Pernell — a suspect in a Saint Lucian murder who escaped custody twice before entering the U.S. under an assumed identity — was sentenced to nearly three years in federal prison on firearms charges. Following the completion of his sentence, U.S. authorities confirmed Pernell will be extradited to Saint Lucia to face the original murder charge that first put him on law enforcement radars across the region.
Pernell’s long history of flight from justice traces back to August 2020, when residents of Gros Islet, Saint Lucia reported hearing gunshots that led to the discovery of 45-year-old Cleus Alfred’s body. Two months later, local prosecutors officially charged Pernell with Alfred’s murder. He was first held at the Babonneau Police Station, where investigators say he used a sharp implement to cut through steel cell bars and escape alongside three other detainees, fleeing across the Caribbean to Jamaica.
Jamaican authorities recaptured Pernell in July 2021 via the Jamaica Constabulary Force’s elite Fugitive Apprehension Team, holding him at the Central Police lock-up to await extradition back to Saint Lucia. But just five months later, in December 2021, Pernell escaped custody a second time, remaining at large for nearly a year before attempting to enter the U.S.
U.S. Border Patrol first intercepted Pernell in December 2022 at the San Ysidro, California port of entry, where he presented himself for entry under the false name Oneil Christopher Reid. With immigration proceedings still pending, he was granted temporary entry and released on parole. Over the next two years, Pernell would run afoul of U.S. law enforcement multiple times: first in July 2023, when he was arrested for evading police, speeding, driving without a valid license, and possession of a stolen motorcycle and stolen 9mm handgun. He posted bail and was released within two months, only to be apprehended again in April 2025 in Hinesville, Georgia. A search of his Georgia residence turned up a second stolen handgun and a high-powered assault rifle equipped with a loaded high-capacity magazine.
By April 2025, the St. Lucia Times had already reported that Saint Lucian law enforcement was coordinating with U.S. authorities to secure Pernell’s extradition once he was taken into custody. On February 11, 2026, Pernell entered a guilty plea to one count of illegal firearm possession by an undocumented alien, the charge that led to this week’s sentencing. District Judge Tiffany R. Johnson handed down a 33-month prison term, a sentence that federal prosecutors say fits the gravity of Pernell’s repeated endangerment of U.S. communities.
In an official statement released the same day as the sentencing, U.S. Attorney Theodore S. Hertberg emphasized the scope of Pernell’s criminal trajectory. “After he was charged with murder, Pernell escaped custody twice in the Caribbean, entered the United States under a different identity, and then repeatedly endangered our community through his possession of stolen and high-powered firearms,” Hertberg said.
Law enforcement officials also noted that even while in pretrial federal custody, Pernell continued efforts to escape, repeatedly damaging his cell walls in an apparent attempt to break free. Senior agency leaders framed the conviction and sentencing as a victory for transnational law enforcement cooperation. ATF Atlanta Division Assistant Special Agent in Charge Ryan Todd highlighted the role of federal firearms investigators in removing dangerous offenders from American communities, saying “This case highlights ATF’s critical role in tracing illegal firearms, disrupting trafficking networks, and ensuring dangerous offenders are removed from our communities.”
Steven N. Schrank, Special Agent in Charge of Homeland Security Investigations for Georgia and Alabama, echoed that commitment to accountability. “No one who flees justice abroad and threatens public safety in the United States will escape accountability,” Schrank said. “Through the coordinated efforts of HSI and our partners, Pernell has been apprehended, convicted, and when his sentence concludes, will be returned to face murder charges in Saint Lucia.”