West Indies Test captain Roston Chase has pinpointed consistent first-innings batting failures as the decisive element behind his team’s 2-0 Test series defeat against New Zealand, concluding a grueling multi-format tour in 2025. This assessment came following a comprehensive loss in the final Test at Mount Maunganui on December 22, which sealed a dismal overseas campaign that saw the Caribbean side fail to secure a single victory across all formats.
Chase emphasized that establishing a strong first-innings total, ideally around the 300-run mark, is fundamental to controlling a Test match and pursuing a favorable outcome. He confirmed that early batting inconsistencies have been a persistent issue for the squad, one that proved exceedingly costly throughout the tour. The team’s struggles were starkly evident in the final Test, where a monumental 323-run opening partnership from New Zealand’s Devon Conway (227) and captain Tom Latham (137) led to a commanding host declaration at 575/8. Although the West Indies mounted a stern reply with 420 runs, a subsequent second-innings collapse for 138 all out confirmed a heavy defeat.
The skipper expressed visible disappointment, particularly as the defeat extended the West Indies’ winless streak in New Zealand since 1995. He admitted the pitch’s rapid deterioration, with developing cracks and unpredictable bounce, presented an unexpected challenge for his batsmen. While defending his bowling unit’s effort amidst injury concerns, Chase was unequivocal that batting remained the central weakness, despite being encouraged by three centuries scored in the series, including a brilliant unbeaten 202 from Justin Greaves and 140 from Shai Hope in Christchurch.
On a personal note, Chase was self-critical, labeling his own performance with a highest score of 29 as ‘very below par’ and admitting he failed to lead from the front. Looking ahead, he stated that addressing these deficiencies is non-negotiable for both himself and the team to compete more consistently on the international stage. He also praised New Zealand’s standout performers, including Jacob Duffy’s bowling effectiveness and the dominance of Conway and Latham, while paying tribute to the exceptional career of Kane Williamson.