Police silent on delays in misconduct hearings

Nearly 16 months after a viral clip showing an American detainee being denied bathroom access and forced to relieve herself on the floor of the East Street South police station ignited widespread national public fury, the two rank-and-file officers facing disciplinary charges over the incident have yet to receive a formal ruling, with Royal Bahamas Police Force leadership declining to explain the prolonged delay. A second separate high-stakes disciplinary proceeding has also been frozen in limbo for 10 months: two officers suspended from active duty over a widely circulated video that purportedly captures one of them attempting to solicit a bribe from a visiting tourist during a routine traffic stop are still awaiting a final decision on their fates. In a press briefing with The Tribune yesterday, Chief Superintendent Leonard Ramsey, the force’s official media liaison, confirmed that both cases are currently pending review before the internal Police Tribunal, the specialized body tasked with adjudicating disciplinary violations for serving officers. Ramsey offered no substantive justification for the extended holdups, nor did he provide any projected timeline for when either case would conclude with a formal ruling. The Tribune’s newsroom has submitted multiple follow-up inquiries to police leadership over the past year seeking updates on the status of both proceedings, including formal confirmation of any Tribunal rulings that may have been issued behind closed doors, and has received no substantive responses to date. One year prior to Ramsey’s comments, Police Commissioner Shanta Knowles had publicly stated that the severity of the charges against the two East Street South station officers was significant enough to justify formal recommendations for their immediate dismissal from the force. Back in March of this year, Knowles had also announced that hearing dates had been formally scheduled for both pending disciplinary cases, but acknowledged at the time that she could not specify exact start dates for the proceedings or a projected window for the Tribunal to deliver its final verdicts. The explosive East Street South station video that sparked the initial public backlash spread like wildfire across local and international social media platforms in July 2025: the footage captured a visibly distraught, partially undressed American woman in police custody defecating on the station’s concrete floor after making repeated, desperate pleas to be granted access to a restroom. Off-camera audio, widely verified to be the voices of on-duty officers, can be heard taunting and mocking the distressed detainee as the incident unfolds. The viral clip prompted an immediate internal affairs investigation, and the two implicated officers were formally interdicted shortly after, meaning they were stripped of all active policing duties while disciplinary proceedings moved forward. The separate alleged bribery case traces back to January of this year, when a Miami-based tourist visiting Nassau as part of a cruise itinerary posted a clip to TikTok that he had recorded using AI-equipped smart sunglasses during a roadblock near St Matthew’s Anglican Church, just off Shirley Street. The tourist stated in his accompanying post that the interacting officer had implied the alleged traffic violation could be “resolved informally” in exchange for a payment, rather than issuing him a formal traffic citation that would incur fines or penalties. Commissioner Knowles confirmed at the time that two officers had been pulled from all frontline patrol duties and formally referred to the Police Tribunal to face disciplinary proceedings related to the incident. Five months after that bribery case first surfaced, two additional officers were formally arraigned in Magistrate’s Court on criminal extortion charges, following a complaint from a U.S. tourist who stated he had been targeted for a shakedown at the Nassau Cruise Port; Knowles publicly described that separate extortion case as a source of deep embarrassment for both the police force and the nation as a whole. The East Street South police station has come under intensified public scrutiny in the months following the viral detainee mistreatment video. Just last month, police leadership launched a new internal investigation after 23-year-old Lewratta Farisien came forward with allegations that on-duty officers at the East Street South station refused to file her official complaint that she had been physically assaulted by her son’s father and his aunt. Farisien stated that the station’s officers warned her that her boyfriend, who himself serves as a police officer, could face arrest over the incident, and that she risked losing full custody of her two-year-old son if she pursued the complaint. Frustrated by the pushback, Farisien eventually traveled to the separate Carmichael Road Police Station to successfully file her official report. She told local reporters that she is convinced the entire incident would have been buried by East Street South station leadership and swept under the rug if her viral social media post detailing her mistreatment at the station had not been shared thousands of times across local community groups. As of press time, police officials have not released any findings or updates related to that ongoing investigation into Farisien’s complaint.