One of the most beloved longstanding dining staples at Nassau’s famous Arawak Cay Fish Fry district, the formerly well-known OH Andros restaurant, has undergone a complete full-structure demolition and reconstruction, emerging as a brand new two-level venue rebranded as Taste Of The Island Seaside Restaurant, under the continued ownership of long-time operator Moralus Joseph.
First launched back in 2003 with no change to its core ownership or management team across its two decades of operation, the business’s latest overhaul marks a departure from the minor incremental renovations it has rolled out over the years, as every part of the original wooden structure was removed to make way for a purpose-built new facility. Joseph explained the core impetus for the costly full rebuild was the persistent shortage of seating that plagued the original location during peak visitor hours, when large family gatherings and group bookings would regularly leave dozens of patrons waiting for open tables. The new layout boosts total seating capacity from roughly 300 across the old single-level space to 350 split between two distinct dining zones: a warm, wood-finished casual dining area on the ground floor that is already fully open to the public, and a sleek, chic contemporary upper level scheduled to welcome its first guests on December 1, with a formal grand reopening event planned to invite patrons to tour the new space and capture views of the adjacent waterfront.
As part of the refresh, the menu has been expanded to add a slate of new popular offerings including braised oxtail, slow-smoked barbecue ribs and chicken, zesty garlic wings, and crispy calamari, alongside a greatly expanded fritter selection spanning seafood, vegetable, shrimp and lobster varieties. Joseph noted that a small number of menu items will see a $1 to $2 price increase, a change he emphasized is not tied to the renovation costs, but rather reflects ongoing widespread industry rises in food supply costs, paired with upgraded, more generous portion sizes for all dishes.
The expansion will also allow Joseph to grow his current 25-person staff roster to a team of 40 to 50 full and part-time employees to support the larger operation. He also took the opportunity to clarify a common public misconception tied to his surname, noting that while his family heritage is Haitian, he is a naturalized Bahamian citizen fully rooted in the local community.
The landmark reopening comes exactly one year after a devastating November 16, 2025 fire ripped through the tightly packed wooden stalls of the Arawak Cay Fish Fry, leveling six popular local restaurants including Goldie’s, Rake and Scrape, Red Snapper and On The Edge. At the time, the local Fish Fry vendors association confirmed none of the destroyed businesses carried fire insurance, and the disaster sparked widespread public debate over longstanding safety concerns about the district’s dense cluster of unprotected wooden structures.
