In a dramatic courtroom development, two men accused of a 2019 double homicide in Tobago were unconditionally discharged by the High Court after prosecutors unexpectedly declined to present any evidence against them. Nicholas Davis and Antonio McEachnie, who had faced murder charges for nearly three years, walked free following the procedural collapse of the State’s case during a sufficiency hearing on December 8.
The case concerned the tragic deaths of John Mills, 69, and Eulyn John, 61, a Tobago couple whose bodies were discovered at their Buccoo residence on May 2, 2019. After three years of investigation, authorities arrested Davis and McEachnie in 2022, setting in motion a legal process that would encounter multiple procedural hurdles.
Prosecutors had previously obtained several extensions to compile their evidence, eventually submitting over 50 witness statements. In a unusual maneuver, they also sought permission to call a witness for oral testimony after she refused to swear to her written statement.
During the hearing before Master Margaret Sookraj-Goswami, defense attorneys raised vigorous objections to documents served after court-ordered deadlines, arguing that the late filing—mere days before the crucial hearing—prevented proper review of the materials. The defense team, comprising prominent legal counsel including Senior Counsel Israel Khan, opposed any further extensions given the State’s history of delays.
Master Sookraj-Goswami ruled that the hearing would proceed with most documents admitted, though two statements filed out of time were excluded. In a stunning turn, when invited to present evidence, prosecutors Kernester Mohammed and Mark Peters declined to tender any of their compiled statements. With no evidence before the court to substantiate the murder charges, the judicial officer had no alternative but to discharge both defendants.
The outcome highlights systemic challenges in criminal prosecutions and raises questions about evidence gathering procedures in serious felony cases.