After a decade of judicial oversight, the Caribbean Court of Justice (CCJ) has formally concluded its monitoring role in the implementation of the 2015 Consent Order, a landmark agreement recognizing the land rights of Belize’s indigenous Maya people. The decision marks a significant milestone in a long-standing legal battle that has shaped the discourse on indigenous rights in the region. However, the court’s announcement has been met with mixed reactions. While the CCJ acknowledged progress in the case, Maya leaders expressed profound dissatisfaction. Attorney Leslie Mendez criticized the Belizean government for its perceived lack of commitment and alleged bad faith throughout the process. Conversely, government attorney Andrew Marshalleck emphasized the complexities of balancing Maya land rights with the interests of other Belizean citizens. Justice Winston Anderson, in his closing remarks, underscored the importance of these rights as essential tools for dignity, development, and peaceful coexistence, rather than mere historical artifacts. The case highlights the ongoing challenges in reconciling indigenous rights with broader national interests.