First charges under new Anti-Gang Law

More than 24 months after Bahamas Prime Minister Philip Davis made a sweeping public pledge to crack down on every individual connected to criminal street gangs, the nation’s very first case prosecuted under his administration’s landmark Anti-Gang Act is finally scheduled to go before the Supreme Court, with two defendants facing combined charges of gang affiliation and grievous bodily harm tied to a 2022 altercation. The two accused men, identified as Davonne “Von” Brown Jr and Cedric “CJ” Thompson, were initially served charges of inflicting dangerous harm following a May 10, 2022, incident where prosecutors allege they severely injured Anton Newbold, a man documented as a member of a rival criminal faction operating in the eastern New Providence area. Prosecutors have since added formal gang membership charges, asserting the pair are affiliated with an organized gang based in that same eastern New Providence jurisdiction. “These two men already had an active pending charge related to that 2022 assault, and subsequent investigative work uncovered additional corroborating evidence linking them to gang activity, so we moved to add charges under the dedicated anti-gang legislation,” Director of Public Prosecutions Cordell Frazier confirmed to The Tribune in an exclusive interview. “The gang-related count has been appended directly to their existing court matter.” During a pre-trial case management hearing on Tuesday, Supreme Court Justice Franklyn Williams formally notified both defendants that their full trial is slated to kick off the following May. If found guilty of the standalone gang membership charge, each defendant could face a maximum prison sentence of 25 years. This upcoming high-profile trial represents the first real, on-the-ground test of the sweeping legislation Prime Minister Davis once framed to the Bahamian public as the definitive solution to a years-long surge in gang-related violence and cycles of retaliatory tit-for-tat killings. “We will table the toughest Anti-Gang Legislation this nation has ever seen. If you have any ties to a criminal gang, we will track you down and hold you accountable,” Davis stated in a national televised address shortly before the bill was tabled for parliamentary debate. The Anti-Gang Act was formally passed by the legislature in April 2024 and officially entered into force on August 1 of that same year, but for nearly 18 months following its enactment, repeated public promises of imminent prosecutions failed to translate to actual cases making their way to the courts. In February 2025, Royal Bahamas Police Force Commissioner Shanta Knowles revealed that investigators were actively building the first case under the new law, and expressed optimism that suspects would be formally arraigned before the judiciary in short order. Six months after that announcement, Prime Minister Davis himself told reporters that charges under the act would be issued “very shortly”, noting that law enforcement and prosecution teams were conducting final reviews of a small number of case files. By January of this year, however, Commissioner Knowles disclosed that police had encountered an unforeseen “roadblock” in enforcing the law, and that her team was in active negotiations with the Office of the Director of Public Prosecutions to push for unspecified targeted amendments to the legislation. The critical gap law enforcement had identified was a lack of robust legal protections for civilian witnesses willing to testify against violent gang members. By September 2025, then National Security Minister and current Attorney General Wayne Munroe confirmed that the Davis administration planned to revise the act to include those enhanced witness safeguards. In March of this year, Munroe announced that anti-gang investigations had reached a “critical operational juncture” after new rules granting temporary court-approved anonymity to cooperating witnesses were formally laid before Parliament. “The police explicitly requested formal legal provisions for witness anonymity, and I tabled that amendment in Parliament just two weeks prior to that update,” Munroe explained. The penalties outlined in the Anti-Gang Act extend far beyond simple convictions for gang membership. Any individual found guilty of gang-linked criminal activity — a broad category that includes committing a serious offence to benefit a gang, carrying out acts of retaliation on a gang’s behalf, or committing kidnapping or extortion at a gang’s direction — faces a maximum fine of $100,000 alongside a 25-year prison sentence. In cases where gang-related criminal activity results in a fatality, every identified gang leader, participating member, and any other individual proven to have contributed to the fatal act is liable to a mandatory life prison sentence. The legislation defines a criminal gang as three or more people, organized either formally or informally, who collaborate or act independently with the shared objective of carrying out gang-related criminal activity. Prosecutors are permitted to submit a wide range of evidence to prove gang membership in court, including suspect admissions, gang-affiliated tattoos, branded clothing, symbolic markers, coded communication, public statements made on a gang’s behalf, and documented patterns of association with known gang members. Additional offences under the act include retaliating against an individual for refusing to join a gang, leaving a gang, or providing evidence against gang members, which carries a maximum 20-year prison sentence, as does the offence of intentionally harbouring a known gang member. This latter provision drew sharp public criticism from Opposition Leader Michael Pintard, who warned that it could lead to unjust prosecutions of parents whose minor children are involved in gang activity. Senior legal and law enforcement officials have repeatedly noted that successful enforcement of the Anti-Gang Act requires months of meticulous, targeted intelligence gathering to build airtight cases that can withstand rigorous judicial scrutiny, and that their enforcement strategy targets not just the street-level perpetrators of violent crimes, but the shadowy organizers and financial backers who sustain gang operations behind the scenes. This is not the first time Bahamian authorities have attempted to enforce anti-gang legislative provisions: back in 2015, a group of men who became the first to face charges under a 2014 Penal Code amendment that criminalized gang membership saw all their charges dismissed within 30 days, after a Supreme Court justice ruled that no documentation had been submitted to the court confirming the exact date that 2014 amendment had formally entered into legal force. Veteran prosecutor Basil Cumberbatch, Assistant Director of Public Prosecutions, will lead the crown’s case for the upcoming landmark trial.