KINGSTON, Jamaica — In a emotionally charged courtroom development that has captured national attention, Constable Noel Maitland has been found guilty of murder and preventing the lawful burial of his girlfriend, Donna Lee Donaldson, who vanished in July 2022. The verdict delivered Thursday at the Home Circuit Court marked a pivotal moment in a case that has highlighted issues of gender-based violence and police accountability in Jamaica.
The conviction came after extensive deliberation by the jury, which determined Maitland’s culpability in the disappearance and presumed death of the 24-year-old victim, whose body has never been recovered. The case centered on Donaldson’s last known whereabouts at Chelsea Manor Apartments in St. Andrew, where the accused police officer resided.
Sophia Lugg, the victim’s mother, responded to the verdict with tearful gratitude, addressing supporters and media outside the courthouse. ‘To all my Jamaican people, to each and everyone all over this world, thank you very much for standing with me,’ Lugg declared. ‘The verdict has passed and victory belongs to us.’
When questioned about Maitland’s emotional display upon hearing the verdict, Lugg offered a philosophical perspective: ‘Tears are a language for even the murderers. God understands, he knows why he cries.’
The Director of Public Prosecutions, Claudette Thompson, described the outcome as ‘bittersweet,’ noting that while justice had been served, the verdict confirmed the tragic reality of Donaldson’s fate. ‘It is not a moment for us to rejoice,’ Thompson stated. ‘It is acceptance that the jurors returned the correct verdict.’
Lugg vowed to continue seeking answers about her daughter’s final resting place while expressing gratitude to Jamaica’s justice system, the Office of the Director of Public Prosecutions, and the jury members who participated in the proceedings.