KINGSTON, Jamaica — Jamaica’s Supreme Court has delivered a landmark ruling against the nation’s police leadership, declaring that senior commanders exceeded their legal jurisdiction when disciplining an officer over a controversial TikTok video. Justice Tania Mott Tulloch-Reid determined that the Jamaica Constabulary Force (JCF) leadership violated established Police Service Regulations in their handling of the case involving Constable Miskha Sterling-Gibson.
The judicial review centered on a January 2024 social media post featuring three uniformed officers participating in a viral trend. The video contained satirical commentary about police privileges, including skipping fast-food queues and using sirens to avoid traffic. While the JCF High Command initially deemed the content damaging to the force’s reputation, the court found the disciplinary response legally unsound.
Specifically, the court invalidated actions taken by Deputy Commissioner Richard Stewart, who ordered the constable to undergo six months of confinement training at the National Police College of Jamaica—far exceeding the three-day maximum permitted under regulations. The ruling also condemned then-Senior Superintendent Michael Phipps for imposing duplicate punishment during an orderly room hearing in March, after the officer had already received sanctions for the same incident.
In her decisive judgment, Justice Tulloch-Reid declared that all illegitimate sanctions were quashed and that the officer had already fulfilled all legitimate penalties related to the video. The court further ordered each party to bear their own legal costs, establishing an important precedent regarding police disciplinary procedures and officers’ social media rights.