In the wake of Hurricane Melissa’s devastation, a significant debate has emerged in Jamaica regarding the appropriate allocation of government relief funds. The controversy centers on a $75 million allocation announced by Prime Minister Andrew Holness on December 23 specifically designated for rebuilding damaged churches and faith-based institutions.
The funding decision faced immediate criticism from Member of Parliament Everald Warmington, who publicly questioned the rationale behind directing resources toward religious structures rather than addressing the critical housing shortage affecting thousands of displaced Jamaicans. Warmington argued that the amount would be insufficient for meaningful church reconstruction and suggested congregations should share facilities instead.
Religious leaders across denominations have responded with a unified message: their primary mission remains humanitarian aid, not architectural restoration. Bishop Dr. Rowan Edwards, chairman of the 10,000 Men and Families Movement, emphasized that while appreciating the government’s gesture, congregations would prioritize assisting homeless members before considering building repairs.
“The money that they would give to the church, we would use that money to help our people, to get back their roofs,” Edwards told the Jamaica Observer. “We prioritize our people, apart from the building.”
Bishop Dr. Peter Garth of Hope Gospel Assembly offered a nuanced perspective, acknowledging the mathematical reality that $75 million distributed among numerous damaged churches would provide limited reconstruction funds. However, he challenged Warmington’s characterization of churches as financially secure institutions with empty pews, pointing out the logical inconsistency in these claims.
Rather than rejecting government assistance entirely, religious leaders proposed an alternative approach. Garth suggested the funds be converted into building materials that could be distributed directly to families in need, noting that churches have served as first responders since the hurricane struck on October 28.
Father Sean Major-Campbell of the Anglican Diocese provided crucial context, explaining that many congregations face financial struggles despite public perceptions of wealth. He highlighted the ongoing social support work performed by churches in education, healthcare, and welfare—often without state assistance—and advocated for continued cooperation between religious and government entities in national development efforts.
The consensus among religious leaders demonstrates a practical approach to disaster recovery that places human needs above structural concerns, while simultaneously defending the vital community role played by faith-based organizations in Jamaica’s social fabric.