Amid mounting pressure for the dismissal of head coach Daren Sammy following a prolonged winless streak in Test cricket, a senior Cricket West Indies (CWI) official has vehemently defended the former captain, arguing that a coaching change would be a superficial solution to deeply rooted systemic problems.
Dr. Donovan Bennett, a CWI Director and President of the Jamaica Cricket Association, has publicly stated that sacking Sammy is not the answer to the team’s persistent struggles. This stance comes in the wake of the West Indies concluding their 2025 campaign with a crushing 323-run defeat to New Zealand at Bay Oval, resulting in a 0-2 series loss. The team’s performance under Sammy has been historically poor, marking the worst start for any West Indies coach in nearly a decade, with only a single drawn Test against New Zealand preventing a complete whitewash in recent series against Australia, India, and the Black Caps.
Bennett contends that the core issues plaguing West Indies cricket are structural and originate far from the senior team’s dressing room. In an interview with the Jamaica Observer, he pinpointed chronic deficiencies at the franchise and age-group levels as the primary culprits. He presented a compelling historical argument, noting that the team’s fortunes have remained unchanged despite a revolving door of seven or eight coaches over the past decade, including high-profile appointments from Australia and elsewhere.
Emphasizing the need for a holistic, long-term strategy, Bennett asserted that success on the global stage will only be achieved through a fundamental overhaul of youth development programs. He advocates for instilling not just technical excellence but also a profound sense of commitment and regional pride in emerging players from a young age, creating a robust pipeline of talent equipped for international competition.
The statistics underscore the severity of the crisis. The West Indies have managed only five victories in their last 25 Test matches and currently languish at the bottom of the 2025-2027 ICC World Test Championship standings with a mere four points. As the team looks ahead to a home series against Sri Lanka in the summer, the debate ignited by Bennett’s comments shifts the focus from a quick fix to a necessary, albeit challenging, systemic renaissance.