In a significant ruling from the St Catherine Parish Court, 39-year-old steel worker Robert Wallace was exonerated on Thursday of two counts of indecent assault. Presiding Judge Justice English-Myers delivered the acquittal after determining that the prosecution’s case suffered from fundamental inconsistencies and insufficient credible evidence to secure a conviction.
The allegations against Wallace involved a minor and stemmed from two separate incidents reportedly occurring in December 2023 and May 2024. The prosecution’s case rested primarily on the testimony of the complainant and her older sister, both of which unraveled during cross-examination by defense attorney Rodain Richardson.
Critical to the defense’s success were numerous discrepancies in the complainant’s account. The court noted that the complainant admitted to providing false information to police regarding how a door opened during one alleged incident—a contradiction Justice English-Myers described as both material and troubling. The timeline of events presented by the complainant shifted repeatedly, particularly concerning whether the December incident occurred before or after an ongoing family dispute.
Further weakening the prosecution’s narrative, the complainant’s sister conceded under oath that portions of her written statement—including claims of discomfort and inappropriate looks from Wallace—were untrue. She acknowledged having maintained a positive relationship with Wallace until the family disagreement emerged.
The court also found the complainant’s behavior inconsistent with the gravity of the allegations. Testimony revealed she neither screamed, cried out, nor reported the incidents to any family members present in Jamaica at the time, including her grandmother, father, or sister.
Additional testimony from the grandmother, who was present in the home during the relevant period, indicated that the complainant was never left alone with Wallace and visited infrequently, further undermining the prosecution’s case.
In her ruling, Justice English-Myers concluded that the complainant lacked credibility as a witness due to multiple contradictions, evolving timelines, and unsupported claims. The court determined that the Crown failed to meet the burden of proof beyond reasonable doubt, resulting in Wallace’s acquittal on both counts.
Following the verdict, Wallace expressed quiet gratitude to his legal counsel for their unwavering support throughout the proceedings before reuniting with his family outside the courtroom.