Muriel Lightbourn, President of the Bahamas Nurses Union, has publicly accused Health and Wellness Minister Dr. Michael Darville of hypocrisy regarding the suspension of public health nurses. Since assuming office in 2023, Lightbourn revealed that over 30 nurses have been suspended, with some cases occurring as recently as three weeks ago. Although three nurses have since returned to work, Lightbourn criticized the Public Hospitals Authority (PHA) for what she described as excessive disciplinary measures. She specifically questioned Dr. Darville’s sincerity after he expressed concern over the suspension of veteran nurse Pearl Williams, calling his remarks ‘disingenuous’ given his silence in other cases. Lightbourn highlighted the flawed disciplinary system within the PHA and called for reforms to ensure fairness and efficiency. She emphasized the union’s intention to revisit its industrial agreement to address these issues and prevent future occurrences. The controversy stems from the suspension of Williams, a 44-year veteran, who was disciplined for recording a video exposing poor conditions at Princess Margaret Hospital, including leaking roofs, rodent infestations, and supply shortages. The PHA accused her of violating its social media policy and imposed strict restrictions, including surrendering her identification badge and limiting her hospital access. Lightbourn argued that such punishments are overly harsh and strain already limited hospital resources. She also criticized the prolonged investigation process, suggesting that warnings or relocations would be more appropriate than suspensions. Dr. Darville defended his ministry, stating that he is not directly involved in all human resources matters and that suspensions are necessary for policy violations. Lightbourn further called for greater transparency in disciplinary proceedings, noting that nurses are often left uninformed about investigation outcomes. She defended her leadership style, emphasizing that her preference for private negotiations should not be mistaken for inaction. Meanwhile, Williams expressed hope that her case would prompt authorities to address the systemic issues she raised, though she has no plans to pursue legal action.
BNU chief accuses Darville of hypocrisy on ministry’s handling of suspended nurses
